Insurance broker / Insurance questions / Car insurance

When is comprehensive car insurance worth it in Germany?

In short

Comprehensive cover (Vollkasko) is usually worth it for new, financed, leased and expensive cars, roughly in their first three to five years. It also pays for accidents you cause and for vandalism. Once the car is worth only a few thousand euros, or the cover costs more than a tenth of that value each year, partial cover (Teilkasko) is often enough.

Request a quote +49 3375 29 12 77

When is comprehensive car insurance worth it in Germany?

What it costs

Published averages, including liability.

Example	Typical range
Liability with comprehensive cover, average	about EUR 570 a year
Liability with comprehensive cover, usual range	about EUR 600 to 1,500 a year
Comprehensive part alone	about EUR 400 to 900 a year
For comparison: liability with partial cover	about EUR 350 to 700 a year

Guide values as of September 2026. New drivers and expensive type classes are well above this.

Worked example

Six-year-old car, current value EUR 7,000

Does comprehensive cover still make sense here?

Extra cost over partial cover	about EUR 280 a year
Paid over three years	about EUR 840
Value in three years	about EUR 5,000

Over three years the cover costs about a sixth of the car's value. If you have EUR 5,000 in savings, switching to partial cover is reasonable. Worked example with guide values.

When comprehensive cover clearly fits

With leasing or a car loan, the lender almost always requires it. Beyond that: if a total loss you caused yourself would hit you hard financially, you should have it.

For new drivers it is expensive, but that is exactly when it protects you from the cost of a driving mistake on your own car.

What is different if you come from abroad

German comprehensive cover is similar to collision plus comprehensive in the US, but it is priced through your no-claims class. If your driving history from home is not recognised, you start in a low class and the own-damage part is expensive at first.

In your first years in Germany, driving on unfamiliar roads with a car you may still be paying off, the cover protects you most. Many newcomers also buy a used car. Then the question is the car's value, not how long you have lived here.

How to do the sums yourself

Compare the extra cost over partial cover with the car's current value. If the extra cost over two or three years eats up a large part of the value, comprehensive cover hardly pays off.

Include the step back in your no-claims class: after a reported claim you pay more for several years.

Situation	Recommendation
New car or up to three years old	comprehensive
Leasing or loan	comprehensive, usually required
Five to eight years, medium value	do the sums, often partial cover
Value below EUR 3,000 to 5,000	partial cover or liability only

When you do not need it

If you could replace the car yourself after a total loss and it is worth little, you usually pay in more than you will ever get back.

To be honest: many people keep paying out of habit. A yearly look at the car's value is worth it.

Step by step

Estimate the car's current value.
Ask for the extra cost of comprehensive over partial cover.
Check whether your leasing or loan contract requires it.
Be honest about your savings.
Recalculate with a higher deductible.

Checklist

New price or purchase price compensation for young cars
Gross negligence included
Protection of your no-claims class checked
Deductible chosen to fit
Car value reviewed every year

Common mistakes

Paying for comprehensive cover for years without checking the car's value
Reporting every small claim and being moved back expensively
Dropping comprehensive cover on a leased car and breaching the contract

Questions and answers

Frequently asked

Up to what car age is comprehensive cover worth it?

As a rule of thumb three to five years. What really counts is the car's value, not its age.

Is comprehensive cover mandatory with leasing?

Not by law, but almost all leasing contracts require it.

Is a high deductible worth it?

Usually yes. Because of the step back in your no-claims class, you often pay small damage yourself anyway.

Does it pay after a hit and run?

Yes, if the other driver is never found, comprehensive cover pays for your car.

Can I switch to partial cover during the year?

Many insurers allow this within the same contract. Ask.

Does it cover me when I drive home to another EU country?

Usually yes, within Europe. Check the area of cover in your policy before long trips.

Sources

NAMMERT insurance broker

Request a quote: Car insurance

We compare several insurers and come back with a proposal. Free for you; the insurer pays our fee. You can write in English.

1Who is it for?

Personal My company

2Which insurance?

Choose as many as you like. For each one, the details an insurer needs for a quote appear below.

Personal

Business

Please review all my existing policies

3Details

Car insurance in Germany (liability, partial and fully comprehensive)

Vehicle (make, model, power) * Most precise with the HSN and TSN codes from the registration document Year of first registration * Current no-claims class (liability) * Annual mileage * Who drives the car? * Cover required * Is the car kept in a garage overnight?

4Your current policy

Current insurer Policy ends on What matters more to you?

5How can we reach you?

Name * Email * Phone Postcode Town Preferred contact Anything else we should know