D&O insurance in Germany: personal liability of a GmbH managing director
A German GmbH protects its shareholders, not its managing directors. A Geschäftsführer who breaches his or her duties is personally liable to the company with private assets, and in insolvency the administrator enforces that claim. D&O insurance pays justified claims and the often considerable cost of defending them.
Can I be personally liable as managing director of a German GmbH?
Yes. Under § 43 of the GmbH Act a managing director who breaches the duty of care of a prudent businessperson must compensate the company for the loss, jointly with any co-directors, for five years. The riskiest phase is a crisis: payments made after the company became insolvent must be refunded personally (§ 15b Insolvency Code). This applies to foreign directors of a German subsidiary just as much as to local ones, and being the sole shareholder does not protect you once an insolvency administrator is appointed.
Most claims come from inside the company
People used to US litigation expect D&O claims from shareholders or regulators. In Germany most claims are internal: the company, or later its insolvency administrator, sues its own managing director for a loss caused by a breach of duty. Typical examples are an unsecured large order, missing insurance, poor supervision of finance staff or a contract signed without the required shareholder approval.
The burden of proof is uncomfortable. The company only has to show a loss and conduct that may have been a breach. The director must then prove that he or she acted with due care. German law protects sound business decisions made on adequate information (the business judgment rule in § 93 of the Stock Corporation Act, applied to GmbH directors by the courts), but only if the decision process can be documented.
Crisis and insolvency: the most expensive phase
German insolvency law sets strict deadlines. Once a GmbH is unable to pay its debts, the managing director must file for insolvency without undue delay and at the latest after three weeks; in case of over-indebtedness the limit is six weeks (§ 15a Insolvency Code). Late filing is a criminal offence.
Every payment made after insolvency has occurred must be refunded to the company unless it was consistent with the care of a prudent manager (§ 15b Insolvency Code). Directors are also personally liable for unpaid company taxes (§ 69 Fiscal Code), and withholding employees' social security contributions is a crime under § 266a Criminal Code. Good D&O wordings state expressly that § 15b claims are covered losses.
Foreign parent, German subsidiary: check where the cover sits
Directors of German subsidiaries are often insured under the parent company's global D&O programme. That can work, but three points need checking: whether the programme includes a local German policy or at least complies with German requirements, whether it covers claims by the subsidiary against its own director, and whether insolvency of the subsidiary is excluded.
Also check how the limit is shared. A global limit is available to all directors of all group companies together. If a large claim in another country uses it up, the German director may be left without cover in the same year.
What is covered
Claims by the company against its directors, board members and supervisory board
Claims by third parties against directors personally
Defence costs for lawyers, experts and courts
Claims by the insolvency administrator, including § 15b refunds if included
Criminal and regulatory defence costs, depending on the policy
Former, current and future directors and senior managers
Directorships in subsidiaries and, if agreed, in outside companies
Past breaches, as far as retroactive cover applies
What is not covered
Knowing breach of duty and intent
Fines, penalties and the taxes themselves
Claims known when the policy began
Personal gain to which the director was not entitled
Bodily injury and property damage, which belong to liability insurance
US claims unless expressly agreed
Who needs it
Managing directors of a GmbH or UG, including shareholder directors
Foreign executives appointed to the board of a German subsidiary
Start-ups with investors, venture debt or several shareholders
Board and supervisory board members of an AG, cooperative or foundation
Employed managing directors without a shareholding
Who does not need it
Sole traders, because there is no company to which a director owes duties
Wheel of misfortune
Spin the wheel of bad luck
Six things that really happen. The wheel picks yours and shows who pays.
Cost:
Budget policy Strong policy
See all six cases
MD keeps paying bills after insolvency, all payments made after that point, often six figures. Budget policy: does not pay, Strong policy: pays. The insolvency administrator can reclaim these payments from the managing director personally. Older wordings leave open whether this counts as damages, strong ones include it expressly.
Unpaid employee social security shares, the missing contributions, often five figures. Budget policy: does not pay, Strong policy: does not pay. Withholding employees' shares is a criminal offence that requires intent, and the MD is personally liable. Intent is never insurable.
Parent company sues the German MD, six figures plus legal costs. Budget policy: pays, Strong policy: pays. Claims from the company or group against its own director are the core of D&O. The policy also pays to defend them.
Prosecutor investigates the MD, defence costs, often five figures. Budget policy: pays in part, Strong policy: pays. Basic wordings pay defence only when a damages claim is involved. Strong policies include criminal defence for directors.
Tax office claims wage tax from the MD, the unpaid wage tax, often five figures. Budget policy: pays in part, Strong policy: pays. Personal liability for company taxes can be covered if the breach was not knowing. Strong wordings say so clearly.
Bank calls the MD's personal guarantee, the guaranteed amount. Budget policy: does not pay, Strong policy: does not pay. A personal guarantee is a contract the director signed himself. D&O covers liability for breaches of duty, not promises to pay.
What it costs
D&O premiums depend on the company, not the individual. Small, profitable GmbHs can use simplified tariffs based on a short questionnaire; larger or loss-making companies are underwritten individually on the basis of their accounts.
What drives the premium
Turnover and total assets
Equity ratio and recent results
Sector, especially financial services and start-ups
Limit and deductible
US subsidiaries or revenue
Listing or planned funding rounds
We do not publish sample D&O premiums, because they vary strongly with the balance sheet even at the same size. Your premium is fixed only in the quote, for which we need the latest annual accounts.
The policy levels on the market
01
Compact policy for small GmbHs
Limits usually from EUR 500,000 to EUR 2 million, questionnaire instead of full underwriting, standard wording. For healthy companies without foreign exposure.
02
Mid-market cover
Individually underwritten, higher limits, separate defence cost limit, criminal defence cover, longer reporting period and express cover for insolvency claims.
03
Group and listed companies
Layered programmes with primary and excess insurers, Side A cover for individuals only and securities claims cover.
How to recognise a good policy
Criterion
Minimum standard
Strong policy
Why it matters
Retroactive cover
for unknown breaches
unlimited
Breaches are often discovered years later.
Extended reporting period
three years
five years or more, free on insolvency or change of control
The limitation period for GmbH directors is five years.
§ 15b Insolvency Code claims
unclear
expressly covered
Refund claims for payments after insolvency are among the most common.
Defence costs
within the limit
additional limit for defence costs
Long proceedings can use up the limit before any damages are paid.
Knowing breach exclusion
applied on the insurer's assessment
only after a final court finding
The insurer should not be able to walk away on a mere allegation.
Insured persons
current directors
former, future and de facto directors and senior managers
Claims often target people who have already left.
Insurer's right to cancel after a claim
yes
no
Otherwise cover disappears exactly when it is needed.
Insurers on the German market
D&O is a specialist market. Several international insurers write German D&O through branches of companies based in other EU countries and therefore do not appear in the BaFin register of German insurers. The list shows only insurers from that register and nothing about who we work with.
Insurer
Background
Allianz
D&O for small and mid-sized companies
AXA
D&O for small and mid-sized companies
HDI Global
industrial insurer of the Talanx group, large companies
HDI
Talanx group, mid-market and professions
Zurich
German entity of the Zurich group
R+V
insurer of the German cooperative banks, also for cooperatives