Insurance broker / Insurance questions / Private pension

Pension insurance or ETF savings plan in Germany: which is better?

In short

For building wealth, the ETF savings plan usually wins: about 0.05 to 0.50 percent fund costs a year against often more than 1 percent effective costs in a policy. The policy wins if you want an income that never stops. If you might leave Germany, the ETF is also easier to take with you, because an early exit from a policy often costs money.

Request a quote +49 3375 29 12 77

Pension insurance or ETF savings plan in Germany: which is better?

What it costs

Figures from published fund data, current German tax rules and consumer information.

Example	Typical range
Fund costs of a broad world ETF	about 0.05 to 0.50 percent a year, commonly 0.20 percent
Effective costs where it gets critical	1 percent a year can eat the whole return in weak years
Effective costs of 2 percent at 5 percent return	cost about 50 percent of the return
Flat tax in a German depot	25 percent plus 5.5 percent surcharge, together 26.375 percent
Partial exemption for equity funds	30 percent of the gain stays tax free
Saver's allowance	1,000 euros a year, 2,000 euros for married couples
Taxable share of a pension starting at 67	17 percent
Guaranteed interest on new policies since 2025	1 percent

Guide values, September 2026. Tax rates and the base rate apply in Germany and change over time; the range of effective costs between low cost net tariffs and expensive commission tariffs is a guide value from our quoting practice. Your result depends on term, tariff and personal tax rate; we obtain the exact offer. No tax advice.

Worked example

100 euros a month for 30 years

Assuming 5 percent return before costs. Tax is not yet included, this only shows the effect of running costs.

Paid in over 30 years	36,000 euros
Depot with 0.2 percent costs a year	about 78,800 euros
Policy with 1.2 percent costs a year	about 66,200 euros
Difference from costs alone	about 12,600 euros

About 12,600 euros ahead for the depot before tax. The tax advantage of the policy has to make up this gap first.

Costs decide most of the outcome

A broad equity ETF costs between 0.05 and 0.50 percent a year. Many German banks and brokers run savings plans with no order fee.

A unit linked pension policy (fondsgebundene Rentenversicherung) carries the same fund costs plus acquisition and administration costs. The German consumer advice centre shows that 1 percent effective costs a year can wipe out the whole return when markets are weak, and 2 percent can eat about half of a 5 percent return.

Compare offers only by the effective costs (Effektivkosten) in the product information sheet. A low administration fee means nothing if the acquisition costs are high.

Item	ETF savings plan	Unit linked policy
Fund costs a year	about 0.05 to 0.50 percent	about 0.05 to 0.50 percent
Cost of the wrapper	none	effective costs, often above 1 percent
Exit in the first years	order fee only	often less back than paid in
Switching funds	sale, tax is due	usually free and tax free inside the policy

Tax: where the policy catches up

In a German depot you pay 25 percent flat tax plus 5.5 percent solidarity surcharge, together 26.375 percent, plus church tax if you are registered. For equity funds 30 percent of the gain stays tax free, so 70 percent is taxed. The first 1,000 euros of investment income a year, 2,000 euros for married couples, are free.

Accumulating funds trigger a small yearly advance lump sum tax (Vorabpauschale), based on a base rate of 2.53 percent for 2025 and 3.20 percent for 2026.

Inside the policy there is no tax during the saving phase. Take a lump sum after age 62 and at least 12 years, and only half of the gain is taxed at your personal rate. Choose the lifelong pension starting at 67, and only 17 percent of each payment is taxable.

Moment	ETF in a German depot	Pension policy
While saving	Vorabpauschale each year	no tax
Switching funds	gain taxed at once	tax free
Lump sum payout	26.375 percent on 70 percent of the gain	half the gain at your personal rate
Paid as a pension	no special benefit	17 percent of each payment when starting at 67
Annual allowance	1,000 euros usable	does not apply

If you might leave Germany

Many people who come to Germany for work do not know yet whether they will stay. An ETF depot can usually be moved to a broker in your new country or simply kept. A pension policy can also continue, but paying from abroad, and how your new country taxes the payouts, needs checking before you sign.

Cancelling a policy in its first years almost always returns less than you paid. If there is a real chance you leave within ten years, that alone often decides in favour of the ETF. US citizens should get tax advice first, because European funds are treated unfavourably under US rules.

When the ETF savings plan is the better answer

When you want to build wealth and decide later how much to withdraw. When your savings rate may vary or pause. When you might need the money before retirement, or want to leave everything to your heirs.

Also while your annual 1,000 euro allowance is not used up: the depot is then ahead on tax as well.

When the pension policy is the better answer

When you want an income that does not stop, because you might live to 95. When you do not want to manage withdrawals in old age. When you expect a high personal tax rate in retirement.

Four conditions: effective costs below 1 percent a year, a guaranteed annuity factor (Rentenfaktor), a free choice of low cost funds and the option to pause premiums. If one is missing, the ETF is the more honest answer.

Many people combine both: a lean lifelong pension for the basics, everything else in a depot. Keep an emergency fund of three to six months of expenses outside both.

Step by step

Decide first: do you need an income that never ends, or free capital?
Think honestly about how likely it is that you leave Germany.
Take the effective costs from the product information sheet and compare them with the ETF cost ratio.
Check whether the annuity factor is guaranteed.
Choose a monthly amount you can keep up for 20 years or more.
Keep an emergency fund of three to six months outside both.

Checklist

Effective costs of the policy below 1 percent a year
Guaranteed annuity factor, not just the current one
Free choice of low cost funds in the policy
Premium pause and top ups possible
Choice between pension and lump sum at the end
Plan for what happens if you move abroad

Common mistakes

Comparing only acquisition costs instead of effective costs
Buying a policy as an investment although you do not want a lifelong pension
Signing a 30 year policy while planning to leave Germany in a few years
Stopping the ETF plan after a bad year on the markets

Questions and answers

Frequently asked

Which is better in Germany, an ETF savings plan or pension insurance?

For building wealth usually the ETF, because it costs less and stays flexible. For an income that never ends, the policy. Many people do both.

How high may the costs of a unit linked policy be?

Look at the effective costs in the product information sheet. Below 1 percent a year is good; well above that it is hard to catch up with a depot.

Do I pay tax on my ETF every year?

For accumulating funds the Vorabpauschale applies, based on 2.53 percent for 2025 and 3.20 percent for 2026. The 1,000 euro allowance usually covers it for smaller depots.

What happens to my ETF depot if I leave Germany?

You can usually keep it or transfer it. Germany may tax unrealised gains on large holdings when you move away, so check this before a move.

Can I keep a German pension policy after moving abroad?

Usually yes, but check payment from a foreign account and how the new country taxes the payouts. Cancelling early often returns less than you paid.

Can I combine both?

Yes. Cover the basics with a lifelong pension and build everything above that in a depot.

Sources

NAMMERT insurance broker

Request a quote: Private pension

We compare several insurers and come back with a proposal. Free for you; the insurer pays our fee. You can write in English.

1Who is it for?

Personal My company

2Which insurance?

Choose as many as you like. For each one, the details an insurer needs for a quote appear below.

Personal

Business

Please review all my existing policies

3Details

Private pension insurance in Germany

Which type of pension are you interested in? * Year of birth * Employment status in Germany * Planned contribution * Planned retirement age How important is a guarantee? * Existing pension contracts and plans For example a pension from your home country, a German company pension, how long you plan to stay

4Your current policy

Current insurer Policy ends on What matters more to you?

5How can we reach you?

Name * Email * Phone Postcode Town Preferred contact Anything else we should know