Skip to content

Insurance broker / Insurance questions / Personal liability

Who pays if I damage someone else's car while clearing snow?

In short

Who pays if I damage someone else's car while clearing snow in Germany? Your personal liability insurance, if you were clearing privately and were careless with a shovel or snow pusher. A small dent costs about EUR 50 to 120 at a workshop. If you clear with a registered vehicle or as a business, other insurance is responsible. Without liability cover you pay yourself.

Who pays if I damage someone else's car while clearing snow?

What it costs

What small damage to a car costs, and what the personal liability insurance that pays for it costs.

ExampleTypical range
Dent, 25 millimetres, removed without paintingabout EUR 50 to 120
Paint damage, 25 millimetres, spot repairabout EUR 50 to 100
Stone chip in the windscreen repairedabout EUR 100 to 200, new windscreen on average around EUR 900
Personal liability for singlesabout EUR 40 to 120 a year
Personal liability for couples and familiesabout EUR 60 to 180 a year
Very good family policies in a consumer testfrom EUR 48 a year

As of November 2026.

Repair prices according to the automobile club, they are not binding and differ between workshops.

Premiums from published ranges and a test from May 2026.

The amounts in the worked example are derived from these.

Which powered machines are covered is set by your policy terms;

the details here follow the insurers' model terms.

We obtain the exact quote.

Worked example

Snow pusher slips and hits the neighbour's car

While clearing the pavement, the pusher slips on an edge of ice. The door of the neighbour's parked car has a small dent and two paint spots. Calculated with the automobile club's price ranges.

Remove the dentEUR 50 to 120
Spot repair of two paint marksEUR 100 to 200
Total damageEUR 150 to 320
Policy without deductiblepersonal liability pays everything
Policy with EUR 150 deductibleyou pay EUR 150, personal liability at most EUR 170

Without a deductible the damage costs you nothing. With a EUR 150 deductible you carry most of it yourself. Without personal liability you pay the whole bill and would have to fight an excessive claim alone.

Why you are liable for the scratch

If your snow pusher slips while clearing, the handle hits a car door or you throw a slab of ice against a wing, you damage someone else's property. Under Section 823 (1) of the German Civil Code (BGB), whoever does this intentionally or negligently must pay for the damage. Negligent means you did not take the care that can be expected in the situation. The fact that you were fulfilling your duty to clear does not change that.

This is exactly what personal liability insurance (Privathaftpflicht) is for. It first checks whether you are liable at all, pays justified claims and rejects unjustified or excessive ones. If the car was parked blocking the pavement, contributory fault of the owner can reduce the amount (Section 254 BGB). The insurer sorts that out, not you over the garden fence.

Shovel, snow blower or plough vehicle: who pays

What matters is what you clear with and for whom. With a shovel, broom or snow pusher you act as a private person, which is the core of personal liability cover. For powered equipment the design matters. The insurers' model terms generally exclude damage from using motor vehicles, but make an exception for vehicles up to 6 km/h and self-propelled work machines up to 20 km/h top speed that are not subject to compulsory insurance. A walk-behind snow blower usually falls under this.

It is different if you clear with a registered vehicle, such as a tractor, quad or off-roader with a snow plough. Then that vehicle's motor liability pays. Anyone working as a paid winter service needs business liability insurance, because professional activity is excluded from personal liability cover.

SituationWho pays for the damage to the other car
Snow pusher slips, scratch in the dooryour personal liability insurance
You clear as a tenant because your lease requires ityour personal liability insurance
Walk-behind snow blower throws grit against the paintyour personal liability insurance, if the machine is covered under your terms
A neighbour clears for you as a favourcovered by your personal liability under the model terms, otherwise his own
Registered tractor or off-roader with snow ploughthe vehicle's motor liability insurance
Commercial winter servicethe service's business liability insurance
Your own car or your spouse's car in the same householdno liability cover, at most the car's Vollkasko

What the car owner gets

The damage to the car is paid, in practice the repair. Small damage can often be fixed locally. The German automobile club gives about EUR 50 to 120 for a 25 millimetre dent and about EUR 50 to 100 for a paint spot of the same size. If a whole part has to be painted, it gets much more expensive.

The insurer pays the car owner, not you. If the owner asks for more than the repair costs, the insurer rejects the excessive part and defends you in court if needed. So do not agree to a fixed amount before the insurer has checked.

Small damage: report it or pay yourself

If you agreed a deductible of EUR 150 or 250, you pay a small scratch yourself anyway. Then it is often easiest to pay the workshop bill directly. Report the incident anyway as soon as the owner asks for more or you are unsure whether more will follow. The law gives you one week for this (Section 104 VVG).

Without a deductible there is nothing against reporting a EUR 80 claim too. Personal liability has no no-claims downgrade like motor insurance.

If your own car was damaged

For the injured party the order is reversed. If you know who did it, contact that person and their liability insurer. If the municipal clearing service or a contractor caused the damage, the municipality or the contractor is the right contact.

If nobody can be traced, only your own Vollkasko remains, with deductible and no-claims downgrade. For a single EUR 100 dent this is usually not worth it.

When you need no extra insurance

There is no separate policy for clearing snow, and you do not need one. Anyone with personal liability insurance who clears by hand or with a small snow blower is covered. Only check if you use a ride-on clearer or another larger powered machine: top speed and registration then matter.

If you rent and do not have to clear at all, you need nothing for this case. Personal liability still makes sense, because it covers every everyday damage to others.

Step by step

  1. Photograph the damage at once: the car, the spot, your tool and the situation on the pavement.
  2. Speak to the owner or leave your name, address and phone number on the car.
  3. Do not agree to a fixed sum, refer to the check by your liability insurer.
  4. Report the damage to your insurer within one week, with photos and the owner's contact details.
  5. Pass the owner's estimate or invoice to the insurer, do not negotiate yourself.

Checklist

  • Personal liability in place, sum insured at least EUR 10 million
  • Deductible known, so you can judge small claims correctly
  • For a snow blower or ride-on machine: top speed and terms checked
  • Registered clearing vehicle has its own motor liability
  • Paid winter service has business liability insurance

Common mistakes

  • Promising the owner a sum on the spot
  • Not reporting the damage for weeks because it looks small
  • Assuming personal liability also pays for the registered clearing vehicle
  • Driving off or clearing on without telling the owner

Questions and answers

Frequently asked

Does personal liability pay if I have to clear as a tenant?

Yes.

Whether you clear as owner or as a tenant with a delegated duty makes no difference.

You clear as a private person, and damage to other people's property is covered.

Is my snow blower covered?

Under the model terms yes, if it is not subject to compulsory insurance and goes no faster than 6

km/h as a vehicle or 20 km/h as a self-propelled work machine.

Your own contract is what counts.

My neighbour cleared for me and damaged a car. Who pays?

The model terms cover people who take over your gritting duty as a favour.

Then your personal liability pays.

If your contract lacks this rule, the neighbour's liability insurance is responsible.

Does liability pay if I hit my own car?

No.

Liability insurance only pays for damage you cause to others.

The same applies to cars of relatives living with you in the same household.

What happens if I have no personal liability insurance?

Then you pay the repair yourself.

For a dent that is manageable, but if a person is injured the same carelessness can cost a fortune.

My car was damaged by someone clearing snow, the culprit is unknown. What now?

Without a culprit only your Vollkasko remains, with deductible and no-claims downgrade.

First ask neighbours and the property manager who cleared that day.

Sources

NAMMERT insurance broker

Request a quote: Personal liability

We compare insurers and come back to you, in English.

Free; the insurer pays our fee.

1Who is it for?
2Which insurance?

Choose as many as you like. For each one, the details an insurer needs for a quote appear below.

Personal

Business

3Details

Personal liability insurance (Privathaftpflicht)

For example work keys, a drone, a small boat, documents in English

4Your current policy
5How can we reach you?

Free of charge and without obligation. A person will get back to you.

Related questions

Updated

Was this useful?