Skip to content

Insurance broker / Insurance questions / Accident insurance

Which is better, accident insurance or basic abilities insurance?

In short

Which is better? Basic abilities insurance (Grundfähigkeitsversicherung) gives broader protection: it pays a monthly pension if you lose an ability such as walking, seeing or using a hand, whether through illness or accident. Accident insurance pays only after an accident, usually as a lump sum. It often costs EUR 60 to 180 a year, basic abilities cover more like EUR 45 to 160 a month.

Which is better, accident insurance or basic abilities insurance?

What it costs

Guide values from published German tariff examples. Accident cover with a EUR 100,000 base sum and 350 percent progression, basic abilities cover with a EUR 1,500 monthly pension to age 67.

ExampleTypical range
Accident insurance, adult, office jobabout EUR 60 to 180 a year
Accident insurance, adult, skilled tradeabout EUR 120 to 260 a year
Basic abilities, office worker, 30about EUR 45 to 80 a month
Basic abilities, roofer, 25about EUR 70 to 120 a month
Basic abilities, professional driver, 35about EUR 95 to 160 a month
Basic abilities with very high benefit level, age 25, in a testunder EUR 1,000 a year

Guide values as of November 2026 from publicly quoted tariff examples.

The values in the worked example are guide values from quoting practice.

Your premium depends on age, occupation and health; we obtain the exact quote.

Worked example

Tiler, 30, unable to get occupational disability insurance

Two cases that are common in his trade, and what each policy would pay.

Accident insurance premium a yearabout EUR 120 to 260
Basic abilities premium, EUR 1,500 pension, a yearabout EUR 840 to 1,440
Knee permanently damaged after a fall from a ladderboth may pay
Knee arthritis without an accident, walking severely restrictedonly basic abilities
Burnout, no physical restrictionneither without an add-on

Basic abilities insurance costs several times as much but covers the more frequent case of illness. Accident insurance makes sense as a low-cost addition, not as a substitute.

Two policies, two triggers

German accident insurance pays when a sudden event acting on your body from outside injures you against your will. That is how section 178 of the Insurance Contract Act (VVG) describes it. If permanent damage remains, it usually pays a lump sum according to the degree of disability. An illness does not trigger any payment.

Basic abilities insurance does not ask about the cause. It pays a monthly pension if you lose an ability named in the contract, such as seeing, speaking, walking or using a hand, and this is expected to last at least six months. Whether you can still work does not matter.

FeatureAccident insuranceBasic abilities insurance
Pays foraccidentsillness and accidents
Form of paymentusually a lump sum, pension as an add-onmonthly pension until the end of the contract
Yardstickdegree of disability by a fixed limb table (Gliedertaxe)loss of a named ability
Mental illnessnot covered, as it is not an accidentonly as an add-on
Health questionsdepending on the tariffdetailed, previous conditions can lead to exclusion
Premiumlowmuch higher, depending on occupation

Why the trigger matters so much

According to a 2025 analysis by a rating agency, only 6.96 percent of occupational disability cases are caused by accidents. Cancer accounts for 16.96 percent, disorders of the skeleton and musculoskeletal system for 17.85 percent and mental illness for 35.75 percent.

Accident insurance therefore covers only a small share of the reasons why people permanently cannot carry on. Basic abilities insurance also covers the physical effects of illness, but mental illness only to a limited extent.

When accident insurance is the better choice

If you already have occupational disability or basic abilities insurance, accident insurance adds capital at low cost for adapting your home or car, or for aids after a serious accident.

For children, pensioners and people who cannot get basic abilities cover because of their health, it is often the only affordable protection. On its own it is not enough to protect your income.

When basic abilities insurance is the better choice

If you do physical work and cannot get occupational disability insurance (Berufsunfähigkeitsversicherung), or only at a very high price, basic abilities insurance usually serves you better. It replaces income on an ongoing basis, even if the cause is an illness.

For office jobs, occupational disability insurance is usually the better choice because it pays as soon as you can no longer do your job. Check it first. Basic abilities insurance is the answer when occupational disability cover is refused or too expensive.

Step by step

  1. First check whether you can get occupational disability insurance at a bearable premium.
  2. If not, ask for basic abilities insurance with a pension close to your net needs.
  3. Compare the list of abilities and the threshold for each one.
  4. Check add-ons for mental illness, fitness to drive and need for long-term care.
  5. Choose accident insurance with a good limb table as a low-cost addition for capital needs.

Checklist

  • Basic abilities pension covers your fixed costs
  • Term until your planned retirement
  • Abilities that matter in your job expressly insured
  • Health questions answered completely and correctly
  • Accident insurance with a base sum of at least EUR 100,000, if you take one out
  • Occupation stated correctly in both contracts

Common mistakes

  • Treating accident insurance as income protection
  • Taking out basic abilities insurance although occupational disability cover would be affordable
  • Assuming mental illness is automatically covered by basic abilities insurance
  • Leaving out previous conditions in the health questions
  • Looking only at the price instead of the thresholds at which an ability counts as lost

Questions and answers

Frequently asked

Can I have both policies at the same time?

Yes.

Both pay independently.

Many people combine a pension from basic abilities cover with capital from accident insurance.

Is basic abilities insurance an alternative to occupational disability insurance?

A limited one.

It pays only when you lose certain abilities,

occupational disability insurance as soon as you can no longer do your job.

Does basic abilities insurance also pay after an accident?

Yes, the cause does not matter.

What counts is whether the insured ability has been lost.

Do I need accident insurance if I have basic abilities insurance?

Not necessarily.

It makes sense if you want capital ready for conversions or aids after a serious accident.

Why is basic abilities insurance so much more expensive?

It also pays for illness and as an ongoing pension until the contract ends.

Illness is far more common than accidents.

For whom is accident insurance alone enough?

For nobody who lives on their income.

For children or pensioners it can work as basic protection.

Sources

NAMMERT insurance broker

Request a quote: Accident insurance

We compare insurers and come back to you, in English.

Free; the insurer pays our fee.

1Who is it for?
2Which insurance?

Choose as many as you like. For each one, the details an insurer needs for a quote appear below.

Personal

Business

3Details

Personal accident insurance (private Unfallversicherung)

Be specific, for example software developer in an office, or electrician on building sites

For example motorcycling, diving, climbing, paragliding

For example accident pension, cover when travelling home, help at home after an accident

4Your current policy
5How can we reach you?

Free of charge and without obligation. A person will get back to you.

Related questions

Updated

Was this useful?