Skip to content

Insurance broker / Insurance questions / Accident insurance

How is the degree of disability assessed in accident insurance?

In short

How the degree of disability (Invaliditätsgrad) is assessed in German accident insurance depends on your wording: arms, legs, eyes and ears follow the limb table (Gliedertaxe), back, head and organs the loss of overall capacity. A doctor must confirm the disability in writing within 15 months. What counts is the condition visible no later than three years after the accident.

How is the degree of disability assessed in accident insurance?

What it costs

What the assessment costs and what it is worth, based on the model wording and published figures.

ExampleTypical range
Exam by the insurer's doctorEUR 0 for you, the insurer also pays lost earnings
Your own second medical opinionabout EUR 1,500 to 5,000
Complaint to the insurance ombudsmanEUR 0, binding up to EUR 10,000
Payout with EUR 100,000 and 20 percent, no progressionEUR 20,000

As of November 2026.

Doctors' fees for your own claim are only refunded up to a share of the sum named in your policy.

Worked examples are guide values from our quoting practice; your own wording decides.

Worked example

Broken wrist, sum insured EUR 150,000, no progression

How the assessment works if the hand stays two fifths impaired after the fracture.

Value of the hand in the limb table55 percent
Impairment two fifths22 percent degree of disability
Arthritis contributed 20 percentno deduction, below 25 percent
Payout (22 percent of EUR 150,000)EUR 33,000

EUR 33,000 as a lump sum. Every percentage point more or less in the report changes the payout by EUR 1,500.

What the degree of disability means

The degree of disability is the percentage by which an accident impairs you permanently. Under section 180 of the Insurance Contract Act (VVG) and the model wording, permanent means expected to last more than three years with no improvement in sight. A fracture that has healed without after effects within a year therefore gives no degree at all.

The payout is the degree times your sum insured. With EUR 100,000 and 20 percent you receive EUR 20,000 as a lump sum. If progression is agreed, high degrees pay more on top. So a few percentage points in the medical report can mean a lot of money.

Limb table or overall assessment

If the injury affects a body part or sense listed in the limb table, only that value applies. The model wording gives 70 percent for an arm, 55 for a hand, 20 for a thumb and 50 for an eye. Partial loss of function gives the matching share: an arm that is impaired by one tenth gives 7 percent.

The back, head, pelvis and internal organs are not in the table. There the doctor asks how far your normal physical or mental capacity is impaired overall, compared with an average person of the same age and sex. Only medical criteria count; your job does not.

Several injured parts are added up, to a maximum of 100 percent.

Finding after the accidentHow it is assessedDegree under the model wording
Thumb completely stifflimb table, full value20 percent
Hand half unusablelimb table, half of 5527.5 percent
Arm impaired by one tenthlimb table, one tenth of 707 percent
Lasting back pain after a vertebral fractureoverall assessment by the doctorno fixed value, case by case
Arm 70 plus hearing in one ear 30 percentvalues added100 percent, never more

The process step by step

Report the accident without delay and get treatment. Within 15 months of the accident the disability must have arisen and been confirmed in writing by a doctor, and you must have claimed it with the insurer. Claiming simply means telling the insurer that you expect a lasting impairment. Your policy may allow longer periods; your own wording decides.

Once treatment is complete, the insurer usually has you examined by a doctor of its choice. You must attend; the insurer pays the costs and your lost earnings. Once it has the documents, it must state within three months whether and how much it pays for disability (clause 9.1 AUB 2020). If it accepts, payment follows within two weeks. If only the obligation to pay is clear, you can ask for an advance.

Reassessment: the degree can change

Many injuries have not settled after one year. You and the insurer may therefore have the degree reassessed once a year, up to three years after the accident (section 188 VVG). For children the policy can extend this period. If you want a reassessment, you must say so before the deadline. The insurer must tell you about this right, otherwise it cannot rely on your request being late.

Reassessment works both ways. If it produces a lower degree, the insurer may claim back what it overpaid. Only ask for it if your condition has really got worse.

Deductions: earlier impairment and illness

If the body part was already permanently impaired before the accident, the insurer deducts that earlier impairment (Vorinvalidität). If illnesses such as arthritis or rheumatism contributed to the outcome, the degree is reduced by that share. Under the model wording this only applies from a contribution of 25 percent; your policy may set a higher threshold.

Most disputes arise here. Check whether the report backs up the deduction with findings or simply states it.

If the rating seems too low

The insurer's medical report is not a binding decision. Ask for the full report, have your treating specialist read it and object in writing with reasons. A complaint to the insurance ombudsman (Versicherungsombudsmann) is free and pauses the limitation period while it runs; up to EUR 10,000 the decision binds the insurer. Proceedings are in German. A second medical opinion is mainly worth it for high sums: with EUR 100,000 insured, 10 percentage points are EUR 10,000.

To be honest, with a small degree and a small sum, a second opinion often costs more than you could gain. A reasoned objection backed by your own doctor's findings is then the better route.

Step by step

  1. Report the accident at once and collect every medical report from day one.
  2. After a year at the latest, ask your doctor for written confirmation of lasting effects.
  3. Claim the disability in writing within the deadline in your policy.
  4. Attend the exam with the insurer's doctor and describe your problems precisely.
  5. Request the report and check the table value, deductions and reasoning.
  6. If you get worse, request reassessment before three years have passed.

Checklist

  • Deadline for medical confirmation and claim in your calendar
  • Limb table of your policy at hand
  • Findings with measured range of movement, not just opinions
  • Contribution threshold of your policy known
  • End of the three year reassessment period noted

Common mistakes

  • Waiting for treatment to end and letting the 15 months pass
  • Accepting the first decision without seeing the report
  • Asking for reassessment although your condition has improved
  • Not mentioning earlier conditions and being surprised by the deduction

Questions and answers

Frequently asked

Who decides the degree of disability?

First the insurer, based on a medical report.

It is not binding: you can object, go to the ombudsman or sue.

When is the degree assessed?

Usually after treatment is complete.

What counts is the condition visible no later than three years after the accident.

Do I have to see the insurer's doctor?

Yes, if the insurer needs it to check the claim.

It pays the costs and your lost earnings.

Is it the same as the rating from the statutory accident insurance or for a disability card?

No.

Those systems use their own scales.

Your private policy only uses its own limb table and wording.

Does my job count?

No.

Only medical criteria count.

A finger is worth the same for a pianist and a bookkeeper.

Can I bring an interpreter to the exam?

Ask the insurer beforehand.

Describing your symptoms precisely matters, so bring someone if your German is limited.

Sources

NAMMERT insurance broker

Request a quote: Accident insurance

We compare insurers and come back to you, in English.

Free; the insurer pays our fee.

1Who is it for?
2Which insurance?

Choose as many as you like. For each one, the details an insurer needs for a quote appear below.

Personal

Business

3Details

Personal accident insurance (private Unfallversicherung)

Be specific, for example software developer in an office, or electrician on building sites

For example motorcycling, diving, climbing, paragliding

For example accident pension, cover when travelling home, help at home after an accident

4Your current policy
5How can we reach you?

Free of charge and without obligation. A person will get back to you.

Related questions

Updated

Was this useful?