Skip to content

Insurance broker / Insurance questions / Personal liability

What does passive legal protection mean in liability insurance?

In short

What does passive legal protection mean? Your liability insurance fights off unjustified claims against you and pays lawyers, experts and court fees, as § 100 and § 101 of the German Insurance Contract Act (VVG) require. It costs nothing extra: it is part of personal liability insurance at about 40 to 120 euros a year. It does not help you claim money yourself.

What does passive legal protection mean in liability insurance?

What it costs

Passive legal protection costs nothing extra. It is part of the liability premium. Published examples in Germany:

ExampleTypical range
Passive legal protection as an add on0 euros, included
Personal liability, singleabout 40 to 120 euros a year
Personal liability, couple or familyabout 60 to 180 euros a year
Property owner liability, building with 2 flats, 5 million eurosfrom about 36 euros a year

Guide values, May to November 2026, from published premium ranges.

The costs in the worked example are guide values from our quoting practice.

Your premium depends on scope and deductible; we obtain the exact quote.

Worked example

Collision on a cycle path

A pedestrian claims 6,000 euros in pain and suffering and lost earnings after a collision with your bicycle. Two witnesses say she stepped onto the cycle path without looking.

Pedestrian's claim6,000 euros
Review with witnesses and medical recordspaid by the insurer
Lawsuit, lawyers and court at first instanceabout 3,500 to 4,500 euros, paid by the insurer
Judgment: 50 percent contributory fault, 3,000 euros justifiedpaid by the insurer

You pay at most your deductible. Without liability insurance you would have paid the 3,000 euros, your lawyer and your share of court costs yourself.

Passive means you are on the receiving end

In German, Haftpflichtversicherung means liability insurance and passiver Rechtsschutz means passive legal protection. Passive describes your role: you are not claiming anything, someone else wants damages from you. The insurer checks whether you are liable at all and fights the claim if it is wrong or too high, paying lawyers, experts and court fees.

This is a core benefit, not goodwill. Under § 100 VVG the insurer must pay justified claims and defend against unjustified ones. The model terms of the German insurance association list three tasks in clause A1-4.1: checking liability, fighting off unjustified claims and paying justified ones.

PointPassive legal protectionActive legal protection
Your roleyou are asked to payyou want to get something
Which policyliability insurancelegal expenses insurance
Exampleneighbour claims for a water stainyou claim compensation after a fall
Costincluded in the premiumseparate policy, often with a waiting period
Lawyerusually chosen by the insureryour own choice

Where passive legal protection applies

Every liability policy in Germany includes it because § 100 VVG applies to all of them: personal, motor, dog owner, property owner, builder and professional liability. Each one protects you only within its own risk.

If a client accuses you of a professional mistake, personal liability insurance does not help. A car accident belongs to motor liability, a dog bite to dog owner liability. No matching policy means no defence either.

Why legal expenses insurance does not step in

Many people with legal expenses insurance (Rechtsschutzversicherung) expect it to defend them against claims. For damages after an accident or mishap it usually does not. The terms exclude defending damages claims unless they arise from a breach of contract. The Federal Court of Justice confirmed this exclusion in the 2005 terms (judgment of 25 February 2015, IV ZR 214/14).

The reason is a division of labour: defence belongs to liability insurance. Without personal liability insurance you are unprotected against such a claim, even with expensive legal expenses cover.

What the insurer may do and what it pays

With passive legal protection you hand over control. Under clause A1-4.2 of the model terms the insurer may make all statements in your name and run a lawsuit for you at its own cost. It may settle a claim you think is wrong, or refuse a settlement you would prefer.

Under § 101 VVG it pays necessary court and out of court costs even if the claim turns out to be unfounded, and must advance them on request. Litigation costs it causes are paid even beyond the sum insured. If it asks for or approves a criminal defence lawyer, it pays that too (clause A1-4.3).

Limits you should know

There is no cover and no defence for intent. Nor for claims that go beyond statutory liability because you promised more by contract (clause A1-3.3). Admissions or settlements made without the insurer only bind it as far as the claim existed anyway.

You do not need legal expenses insurance for passive protection. It only pays off if you want to enforce your own rights, for example against an employer, a landlord or the other party after an accident.

Step by step

  1. Ask for the claim in writing and promise nothing.
  2. Check which policy applies: personal, motor, dog or professional liability.
  3. Report within one week, pass on a lawsuit or payment order at once.
  4. Tell the claimant your insurer is handling it.
  5. Do not hire your own lawyer without asking the insurer.

Checklist

  • Personal liability policy with at least 10 million euros
  • Dog, car or job insured separately
  • Claim reported on time
  • No admission without the insurer's consent
  • Evidence, photos and witnesses secured

Common mistakes

  • Believing legal expenses insurance defends damages claims
  • Not reporting a claim that looks unjustified
  • Hiring a lawyer yourself and being left with the bill
  • Expecting the insurer to follow your opinion

Questions and answers

Frequently asked

Can I choose my own lawyer?

Usually not.

The insurer is authorised to run the case in your name and picks the lawyer.

What if the insurer pays although I am not at fault?

It may do so, as it controls the claim.

Give it your full account and all evidence early so it can weigh your side.

Does it help in criminal proceedings?

Only if the insurer asks for or approves a defence lawyer and the event can lead to an insured

liability claim.

Does it cover a dispute with my landlord about service charges?

No.

That is a contract dispute, not damages for a mishap.

You need tenancy legal expenses cover for it.

Sources

NAMMERT insurance broker

Request a quote: Personal liability

We compare insurers and come back to you, in English.

Free; the insurer pays our fee.

1Who is it for?
2Which insurance?

Choose as many as you like. For each one, the details an insurer needs for a quote appear below.

Personal

Business

3Details

Personal liability insurance (Privathaftpflicht)

For example work keys, a drone, a small boat, documents in English

4Your current policy
5How can we reach you?

Free of charge and without obligation. A person will get back to you.

Related questions

Updated

Was this useful?