Skip to content

Insurance broker / Insurance questions / Car insurance

Can I mix summer and winter tyres on my car in Germany?

In short

Can I mix summer and winter tyres on my car in Germany? On dry roads the law does not forbid it. Once there is black ice, snow or slush, section 2(3a) StVO requires tyres with the Alpine symbol on all wheels: then a mix costs 60 euros and a penalty point, and comprehensive cover may cut your payout for gross negligence. Your liability cover still pays the other side.

Can I mix summer and winter tyres on my car in Germany?

What it costs

Fines and garage prices that matter for mixed tyres in Germany.

ExampleTypical range
Driving without suitable tyres on icy roads60 euros and 1 point
The same with an accident120 euros and 1 point
Swapping wheels at a garageabout 5 to 10 euros per wheel
Fitting a tyre to a rimabout 15 to 18 euros per tyre
Storing a set of wheelsabout 40 to 170 euros per season
Four new tyres fitted and balancedabout 580 to 800 euros

As of November 2026, from fine tables, garage portals and statutes.

The cut in the worked example is a guide value from quoting practice; courts decide case by case.

Norman Nammert, as an insurance broker,

can check whether your policy waives the gross negligence defence.

Worked example

Two new winter tyres at the front, old summer tyres at the rear

A driver buys only two winter tyres for the front axle in December. On slush the rear slides out in a bend and the car hits a wall. She has comprehensive cover with a 300 euro excess and no waiver of the gross negligence defence.

Repair of her own car4,000 euros
Minus the excess3,700 euros
Cut by a quarter for gross negligenceabout 2,775 euros paid
Fine after an accident120 euros and 1 point
Two more winter tyres fittedabout 290 to 400 euros

She is left with about 1,345 euros from excess, cut and fine. Two more winter tyres would have cost about 290 to 400 euros. Calculation with guide values.

What German law says about mixed tyres

The vehicle registration rules (StVZO) ban only one mix on cars outright: radial and cross-ply tyres may not be fitted together (section 36(6) StVZO). Cross-ply tyres are rare on modern cars, so this hardly matters. There is no rule there against combining summer and winter tyres.

Winter weather changes that. On black ice, packed snow, slush or frost, section 2(3a) of the road traffic regulations (StVO) lets you drive only if all wheels carry tyres meeting section 36(4) StVZO, which means the Alpine symbol, a mountain with a snowflake. Two winter and two summer tyres are not enough. Sizes matter too: only the sizes in your registration papers or an approved report are allowed, otherwise the vehicle's type approval can lapse.

CombinationDry or wet roadIce, snow, slush
Four tyres with the Alpine symbolallowedallowed
Winter at the front, summer at the rearnot banned, but riskyoffence, 60 euros and 1 point
Summer at the front, winter at the rearnot bannedoffence, 60 euros and 1 point
Different tyres on one axlenot banned, technically unwiseoffence if one wheel lacks the Alpine symbol
Radial and cross-ply mixedbannedbanned

Why mixing is risky even without snow

Summer and winter tyres grip differently. With the grippier pair at the front and the weaker pair at the rear, the back of the car can slide out when you brake in a bend. The German automobile club ADAC therefore advises fitting the better tyres to the rear axle, because they keep the car stable in corners.

Tread depth counts as well: in an ADAC test a winter tyre with only 4 mm of tread lost around 12 percent of its braking performance on snow. Stability systems such as ESP can only partly make up for uneven grip, and on four-wheel-drive cars different rolling circumferences can strain the transmission.

What liability and comprehensive cover pay after a crash

Your motor liability insurance always pays the other party. Under section 103 of the Insurance Contract Act (VVG) it is excused only for damage caused intentionally, and mixed tyres are not intent. The tyres can increase your share of the blame, and you lose no-claims classes as with any liability claim.

Damage to your own car is paid by comprehensive cover. If you cause the accident through gross negligence, section 81(2) VVG lets the insurer cut the payout in line with how serious the fault was. The insurer has to show that the tyres helped cause the crash. We have found no court ruling on mixed tyres as such; with summer tyres in winter, courts decide differently depending on the road conditions. If your policy waives the gross negligence defence, the cut usually does not apply.

When a mix is fine

Buying only two new tyres of the same kind is allowed. Have them fitted at the rear and make sure each axle carries a matching pair. If tread or age differ a lot, a full set is usually the better buy.

All-season tyres with the Alpine symbol meet the winter rule. On all four wheels, the mixing question disappears. You do not need a second set if you drive little and live in flat country.

Step by step

  1. Look for the Alpine symbol, a mountain with a snowflake, on all four tyres.
  2. Measure tread: replace winter tyres below 4 mm; the legal minimum is 1.6 mm.
  3. Check field 15 of your registration certificate for the permitted sizes.
  4. If you buy only two new tyres, have them fitted to the rear axle.
  5. Look in your comprehensive cover terms for a waiver of the gross negligence defence.

Checklist

  • Four tyres with the Alpine symbol in winter
  • A matching pair on each axle
  • Better tyres at the rear
  • Only sizes listed in the vehicle papers
  • Comprehensive cover that waives the gross negligence defence

Common mistakes

  • Fitting winter tyres only to the driven axle and thinking that is enough for snow
  • Having the new tyres fitted at the front
  • Counting all-season tyres without the Alpine symbol as winter tyres
  • Not telling the insurer which tyres were fitted

Questions and answers

Frequently asked

May I drive with two winter and two summer tyres?

On dry or wet roads without ice it is not banned.

On snow, ice or slush all four wheels need tyres with the Alpine symbol.

Where do the better tyres go?

On the rear axle, even on front-wheel-drive cars.

They keep the rear stable in bends and under braking.

Does insurance pay if my tyres were mixed?

Liability cover always pays the other side.

Comprehensive cover may cut if the mix was grossly negligent on an icy road and helped cause the

crash.

Can I have different brands on one axle?

There is no express ban as long as size and construction match.

Tyre makers still advise two identical tyres per axle.

Is a space-saver spare a mixed tyre?

A space-saver is only meant to get you to a garage.

Keep to the maximum speed shown on the wheel or in the owner's manual and replace it soon.

Do I get a point for mixed tyres?

Only if you drive on icy roads without suitable tyres on all wheels.

That costs 60 euros and a point, 120 euros after an accident.

Sources

NAMMERT insurance broker

Request a quote: Car insurance

We compare insurers and come back to you, in English.

Free; the insurer pays our fee.

1Who is it for?
2Which insurance?

Choose as many as you like. For each one, the details an insurer needs for a quote appear below.

Personal

Business

3Details

Car insurance in Germany (liability, partial and fully comprehensive)

Most precise with the HSN and TSN codes from the registration document

4Your current policy
5How can we reach you?

Free of charge and without obligation. A person will get back to you.

Related questions

Updated

Was this useful?