Skip to content

Insurance broker / Insurance questions / Cyber insurance

Does cyber insurance still pay if my password was too weak?

In short

Does cyber insurance still pay if my password was too weak? In Germany it often does, though perhaps not in full. No law says a weak password is gross negligence. If the insurer treats it as such, section 81 VVG lets it reduce the payout in line with your degree of fault. Some tariffs exclude gross negligence completely, and then you get nothing. Your policy wording decides.

Does cyber insurance still pay if my password was too weak?

What it costs

Published prices for private cyber insurance in Germany.

ExampleTypical range
Family tariff with EUR 15,000 sum insuredfrom EUR 4.99 a month, about EUR 60 a year
Tariff with legal expenses element, individual (test 2024)about EUR 127 a year
Same tariff, family (test 2024)about EUR 149 a year
Cyber add-on to contents insuranceabout EUR 20 to 50 a year (guide value from our quoting practice)

Guide values from published prices, 2024 to 2026.

The add-on price is a guide value from our quoting practice; we obtain the exact quote.

Worked example

Shop account taken over through a reused password

A fraudster orders goods on invoice through your retailer account. Your password was your first name plus birth year, also used for email. The insurer treats this as gross negligence. Worked example; the percentage is a guide value from our quoting practice.

LossEUR 1,500
Cut for gross negligence30 percent, EUR 450
ExcessEUR 100
Paid by the insurerEUR 950

You are left with EUR 550. Under a tariff that excludes gross negligence outright, it would be EUR 1,500.

What German law says

If you cause the loss through gross negligence, the insurer may reduce its payment in proportion to how serious your fault was (section 81(2) of the Insurance Contract Act, VVG). That is a percentage cut, not an automatic refusal. Only intent frees the insurer completely.

If your policy sets security duties such as strong passwords or current updates, section 28 VVG applies. A grossly negligent breach allows a cut only to the extent it caused the loss. You, however, must prove that you were not grossly negligent.

SituationUsual outcome
12 character password, stolen in a data breach at the providerfull payout, no fault
Short password such as first name plus birth year, account crackeddispute about gross negligence, cut possible
Same password for email and shop, email leak leads to shop fraudcut possible, depending on the terms
Weak password, but the loss came through a fake bank websitepassword strength did not cause it, no cut for that
Tariff expressly excludes gross negligenceno payout once gross negligence is established

What counts as weak

German consumer centres recommend at least 8, better 12 characters from four character types, or at least 25 characters if you use only two types. Use a separate password for each service, a password manager and two-factor login where offered.

Names, birth dates, dictionary words, number sequences and keyboard patterns are considered unsafe. Using them, and reusing them across accounts, hands the insurer an argument.

Your bank comes first

If money left your account or card without your authorisation, your bank is liable first. It may charge you at most EUR 50, unless you breached your duties with gross negligence, in which case you bear the whole loss (section 675v BGB).

That gap is where some cyber policies are useful. Whether yours pays when the bank refuses because of gross negligence is in the terms.

When you do not need cyber insurance

The Hamburg consumer centre advises against standalone cyber policies: cover is often patchy, payouts small, and disputes about adequate protection are common.

German personal liability insurance usually already covers damage you cause others through data exchange, for example by forwarding malware. Check whether your contents or legal expenses policy has a cyber add-on before buying a separate one.

Step by step

  1. Search your terms for gross negligence and for security duties.
  2. Switch to passwords of at least 12 characters, a different one for each service.
  3. Set up a password manager and two-factor login.
  4. After an attack, tell your bank and insurer at once and change your passwords.
  5. Report it to the police and keep a dated record of everything.

Checklist

  • Tariff waives the gross negligence defence or only cuts proportionally
  • Security duties in the policy known
  • No password used twice
  • Two-factor login for email, bank and shops
  • Clear whether the policy pays when the bank refuses for gross negligence

Common mistakes

  • Playing down to the insurer what the password looked like
  • Accepting a refusal without checking whether the password actually caused the loss
  • Choosing a cyber policy on price without reading the gross negligence clause

Questions and answers

Frequently asked

Is a weak password always gross negligence?

No, no law says so.

It depends on how easy it was to guess, whether it was reused and what your policy requires.

Can the insurer refuse completely?

For intent, yes.

For gross negligence the law provides a cut in line with your fault,

but a policy clause can be stricter.

Who has to prove gross negligence?

Where a contractual security duty is involved, you must prove you were not grossly negligent.

Keep a note of how your passwords were built and when you changed them.

Does my bank pay if my online banking was hacked?

In principle yes, and you bear at most EUR 50.

With gross negligence you carry the whole loss.

Is private cyber insurance worth it?

For many people not.

A cyber add-on to contents or legal expenses insurance plus good habits with a password manager

and two-factor login is often the better choice.

What does private cyber insurance cost in Germany?

From about EUR 60 a year, tariffs with a legal expenses element around EUR 130 to 150.

Sources

NAMMERT insurance broker

Request a quote: Cyber insurance

We compare insurers and come back to you, in English.

Free; the insurer pays our fee.

1Who is it for?
2Which insurance?

Choose as many as you like. For each one, the details an insurer needs for a quote appear below.

Personal

Business

3Details

Cyber insurance for businesses in Germany

Rule of thumb: cost of three to four weeks of downtime plus recovery

4Your current policy
5How can we reach you?

Free of charge and without obligation. A person will get back to you.

Related questions

Updated

Was this useful?