Skip to content

Insurance broker / Insurance questions / Car insurance

What does gross negligence mean in comprehensive car insurance in Germany?

In short

In Germany, gross negligence means you ignored a risk that anyone would see, for example driving into a junction long after the light turned red. What does that mean for comprehensive car insurance? Under section 81 (2) VVG the insurer may cut its pay-out in line with how serious your fault was; court rulings range from 25 to 100 percent. Many policies waive this cut, but usually not for alcohol or drugs.

What does gross negligence mean in comprehensive car insurance in Germany?

What it costs

Cuts that German courts have upheld and values from a reference framework used by practitioners.

ExampleTypical range
Red light, fully comprehensive, court ruling50 percent cut
Red light or stop sign, starting value in the Goslar reference framework25 percent cut
Theft with key in the ignition, reference framework75 percent cut
Alcohol from 1.1 per mille, reference framework100 percent cut, case by case
Policy with waiver, no alcohol or drugs0 percent cut, only your excess

As of November 2026, from statute, court rulings and collections of rulings.

Courts always decide case by case.

Damage amount and excess in the worked example are guide values from our quoting practice.

We check whether and how far your policy waives the gross negligence defence and obtain the exact

quote for you.

Worked example

Red light missed, compact car with fully comprehensive cover

A driver enters a junction after the light has been red for some time and collides with a crossing car. Damage to her own car 12,000 euros, excess 500 euros.

Damage to the other carpaid in full by third-party liability, then your no-claims class drops
No waiver, 50 percent cutpay-out 5,750 euros, you pay 6,250 euros
No waiver, 25 percent cutpay-out 8,625 euros, you pay 3,375 euros
With waiverpay-out 11,500 euros, you pay 500 euros

The clause alone decides on up to 5,750 euros here. If alcohol had been involved, the waiver would not have helped.

Ordinary or gross negligence

Ordinary negligence is the everyday mistake: you misjudge a gap or touch a bollard while parking. Fully comprehensive cover (Vollkasko) pays for this, minus your excess.

Gross negligence means you disregarded something that would have been obvious to anyone in that situation, and you can personally be blamed for it. Typical examples are running a red light or a stop sign, typing on your phone and driving on despite clear signs of tiredness.

Not every serious mistake counts. Courts look at each case. A stop sign hidden by dense trees can be missed without gross negligence (Higher Regional Court Hamm, 20 U 125/92). Nodding off at the wheel without prior signs of tiredness did not lead to a cut either (Higher Regional Court Düsseldorf, 1 U 73/01).

How section 81 VVG works

German law no longer follows all or nothing. If you cause the damage on purpose, the insurer pays nothing (section 81 (1) VVG). If you were grossly negligent, it may reduce the pay-out in proportion to how serious your fault was (section 81 (2) VVG).

The law sets no fixed rates. Courts often work in steps of 25, 50, 75 and 100 percent. According to the Federal Court of Justice, a cut to zero is only possible in exceptional cases, such as driving while absolutely unfit through alcohol, and even then mitigating factors must be weighed (judgment of 22 June 2011, IV ZR 225/10).

CaseCourt and file numberCut
Red light, driver said she was dazzled by the sunRegional Court Münster, 15 O 141/0950 percent
Bicycles left on the roof when entering a garageRegional Court Hagen, 7 S 21/1330 percent
Driving on a bus lane, accidentRegional Court Hamburg, 302 O 220/1550 percent
Car key in a sports bag in a changing room, car stolenRegional Court Berlin, 42 O 397/1125 percent
Key in a jacket near a pub door, car stolenRegional Court Cologne, 24 O 283/0990 percent
About 0.3 per mille with signs of impairmentHigher Regional Court Hamm, I-20 U 74/1050 percent

The waiver of the gross negligence defence

Many German Kasko policies include a clause in which the insurer waives the defence of gross negligence. It then pays in full after a red light accident, minus your excess. In newer policies this is often standard, older contracts frequently lack it.

The waiver has limits. It usually does not apply to alcohol or drugs. Many policies also exclude theft that you made easier, for example by leaving the key in view. Intent is never covered. Read the whole clause, because exceptions are sometimes placed elsewhere in the terms.

When the waiver matters less

If you only have third-party liability, the clause does not affect your accident: liability insurance pays the other party even after gross negligence, by law it is only free from paying in case of intent.

For an old car with little value and only partial cover (Teilkasko), the waiver matters less. For a new, financed or leased car with fully comprehensive cover it is one of the most important points in the contract, because a 50 percent cut can quickly reach five figures.

Step by step

  1. Search your Kasko terms for grobe Fahrlässigkeit and read the whole paragraph.
  2. Check which cases are excluded: alcohol, drugs, theft, driving without a licence.
  3. If the waiver is missing, ask your insurer whether it can be added or switch policy.
  4. After an accident describe what happened factually, without calling your own behaviour reckless.
  5. Ask for a written reason for any cut and have the rate checked before you accept it.

Checklist

  • Waiver of the gross negligence defence in the policy
  • Exceptions to the clause known
  • Excess suited to the value of the car
  • Older contract compared with current terms
  • Keys and vehicle papers never visible in the car

Common mistakes

  • Assuming Kasko pays nothing after gross negligence and accepting a cut without checking
  • Thinking the waiver also covers alcohol and drugs
  • Keeping an old contract without the waiver
  • Telling the police at the scene that you did not look at the light at all

Questions and answers

Frequently asked

Is a red light always gross negligence?

Often, but not always.

Courts look at how long the light was red and why you missed it.

A brief moment of distraction can be ordinary negligence.

Do I have to prove I was not grossly negligent?

No.

The insurer has to prove it.

You should still explain your side, because it affects the size of the cut.

Does this also apply to partial cover?

Yes, for example theft with the key in the car.

Here too it depends on whether your policy waives the defence and does not exclude the case.

Does the waiver cost extra?

There is no fixed price.

In many newer policies the clause is standard.

With an older contract, ask whether it can be added for a surcharge and compare that with

switching.

Does the waiver help after drink driving?

As a rule, no.

Policies exclude alcohol and drugs from the waiver, so Kasko may cut,

down to zero if you were absolutely unfit to drive.

Will my no-claims class also drop?

If your fully comprehensive cover pays part of the damage or liability pays the other side,

your class drops as with any settled claim.

The cut comes on top.

Sources

NAMMERT insurance broker

Request a quote: Car insurance

We compare insurers and come back to you, in English.

Free; the insurer pays our fee.

1Who is it for?
2Which insurance?

Choose as many as you like. For each one, the details an insurer needs for a quote appear below.

Personal

Business

3Details

Car insurance in Germany (liability, partial and fully comprehensive)

Most precise with the HSN and TSN codes from the registration document

4Your current policy
5How can we reach you?

Free of charge and without obligation. A person will get back to you.

Related questions

Updated

Was this useful?