Skip to content

Insurance broker / Insurance questions / Car insurance

Who is liable for an accident with an icy windscreen in Germany?

In short

Who is liable for an accident with an icy windscreen in Germany? You are, as the driver: your motor liability insurance pays the victim and may not cut payment for gross negligence. If the other driver shares the blame, your share rises because of the poor view. Comprehensive cover may cut payment for your own car. The fine is 10 euros.

Who is liable for an accident with an icy windscreen in Germany?

What it costs

Published fines for icy windows and snow on the car in Germany, 2026.

ExampleTypical range
Driving with an impaired view, for example a peephole10 euros, no point
Idling the engine while stationary80 euros
Snow left on the roof25 euros
Snow-covered number plate5 euros

As of November 2026, from the fines catalogue, statutes and press reports.

The cut rate in the worked example is a guide value from our quoting practice;

courts decide case by case.

We check whether your policy waives the gross negligence defence and obtain the exact quote.

Worked example

Peephole in the morning, rear-end crash at the lights

A driver scrapes only a peephole and misses the braking car in front at the lights. She has full comprehensive cover with a 300 euro excess.

Damage to the car in front, paid by liabilityabout 4,000 euros
Repair to her own carabout 3,000 euros
Comprehensive with a 50 percent cutabout 1,350 euros paid
Comprehensive with gross negligence waiver2,700 euros paid
Fine for impaired view10 euros

Without a waiver about 1,650 euros stay with her, with a waiver only the excess. In both cases the liability downgrade follows. Calculation with guide values.

What German traffic law requires

Under § 23(1) StVO, the driver must make sure the view is not impaired by the state of the vehicle. An icy or misted windscreen is exactly that. A small peephole scraped into the ice is therefore not enough.

Clear the whole windscreen, the side windows and mirrors, plus rear window, lights and number plate. Only set off once the inside has stopped misting up too.

Liability insurance pays the victim

If you hit a cyclist or the car in front with an icy windscreen, your motor liability insurance pays the victim. Under § 103 VVG it is only released for damage caused intentionally. Gross negligence, such as not clearing the glass, is not enough.

Your no-claims class is downgraded after the accident, as with any claim paid by liability. The icy windscreen does not make the downgrade bigger.

Shared blame: the view counts

When two cars are involved, insurers and courts split the blame. Driving with a restricted view means you must expect part of the liability, even if the other driver, say, failed to give way. What matters is whether a clear view would have let you avoid the crash.

The share that stays with you is only covered for your own car by full comprehensive. Without it, you pay that share yourself.

SituationLiabilityFull comprehensive for your car
Glass clear, other driver at faultthe other side paysnot needed
Peephole, other driver fails to give wayshared liability possiblepays your share, a cut is possible
Peephole, you miss a pedestrianpays the pedestrian in fullcut for gross negligence possible
Single-car crash, glass only partly clearpays third-party property such as a crash barriercut for gross negligence possible
Policy waives the gross negligence defencepayspays in full

When comprehensive cover may cut

If you cause damage to your own car through gross negligence, full comprehensive may reduce payment under § 81(2) VVG in proportion to the severity of your fault. Consumer advisers in Baden-Württemberg warn that insurers are likely to treat driving with a peephole as grossly negligent.

How large the cut is depends on the case. The insurer must show that the poor view caused the accident. You get paid without a cut if your policy waives the gross negligence defence. That clause applies to partial and full comprehensive, but older contracts often lack it.

Winter fines

Driving with an impaired view costs 10 euros under the German fines catalogue, with no penalty point. The fine is the smallest problem: the real cost comes with an accident.

Letting the engine idle to defrost the windscreen costs 80 euros under § 30(1) StVO. A snow-covered number plate costs 5 euros, and snow left on the roof that can slide off while driving costs 25 euros.

When you do not need to scrape

If you park in a garage or use a windscreen cover, you save yourself the scraping. A parking heater also defrosts the glass without the engine running.

If there is no time in the morning, the bus is cheaper than a drive with a peephole.

Step by step

  1. Secure the scene and take photos, including of the windows.
  2. Report the accident truthfully, including the state of the windows.
  3. Look for the gross negligence waiver in your policy terms.
  4. If payment is cut, have it checked whether the view really caused the crash.
  5. Before the next frost, keep a scraper, brush and windscreen cover ready.

Checklist

  • Whole windscreen clear, not just a peephole
  • Side windows, mirrors and rear window clear
  • Inside not misted up
  • Lights and number plate free of snow
  • Full comprehensive with a gross negligence waiver

Common mistakes

  • Setting off with a peephole and hoping the heater does the rest
  • Leaving the engine idling while scraping
  • Hiding the icy windscreen from the insurer
  • Accepting a cut without checking, although the view played no part

Questions and answers

Frequently asked

Does liability insurance pay if I crash with an icy windscreen?

Yes.

The victim is compensated.

Liability insurance may only refuse for intent.

Is a peephole enough?

No.

§ 23 StVO requires an unimpaired view.

Windscreen, side windows and mirrors must be clear.

Do I get a penalty point?

No.

Driving with an impaired view costs 10 euros without a point.

The real costs come through insurance if there is a crash.

How much does full comprehensive cut?

It depends on the severity of fault and is decided case by case.

With a waiver clause in your policy there is no cut.

May I leave the engine running while I scrape?

No.

Unnecessary idling costs 80 euros under § 30 StVO.

A parking heater defrosts without the engine running.

What about a windscreen misted up on the inside?

Same as ice outside: misting also impairs the view.

Turn on the ventilation and fan and wait before you set off.

Sources

NAMMERT insurance broker

Request a quote: Car insurance

We compare insurers and come back to you, in English.

Free; the insurer pays our fee.

1Who is it for?
2Which insurance?

Choose as many as you like. For each one, the details an insurer needs for a quote appear below.

Personal

Business

3Details

Car insurance in Germany (liability, partial and fully comprehensive)

Most precise with the HSN and TSN codes from the registration document

4Your current policy
5How can we reach you?

Free of charge and without obligation. A person will get back to you.

Related questions

Updated

Was this useful?