Home / For international owners / Cover in detail
Sail and rig damage while racing: what the wording decides
Short answer
On the race course the sails are always up, and that is exactly the state many hull wordings exclude when they rule out damage caused by wind on set sails. Whether a blown headsail is paid for turns on one clause and on its exceptions.
A racing claim is rarely a hole in the hull. It is a blown headsail, a bent spinnaker pole, a rig that lets go after a Chinese gybe on the second beat. And that is where a clause bites which a cruising owner may never notice: damage caused by wind acting on set or unfurled sails is excluded in many of the yacht wordings we reviewed. Cruising, sails come down when it pipes up. Around the cans on the Solent, on the IJsselmeer or off Cork, the sails stay up because that is the point of the exercise, so the excluded state is the normal state for the whole afternoon.
What brings the damage back in are the exceptions, and they are the part of the wording worth reading twice before entering a series. The usual three are accident, rig failure and named storm conditions. If the sail tears because the rig comes down, it is rig failure. If it tears because too much cloth stood up for too long in a building breeze, it is wind on set sails. The physical damage looks identical in the yard on Monday morning, so the classification is decided by evidence rather than by the sailmaker, and that evidence is hard to reconstruct once the boat is back on her mooring. Our own hull cover names the tearing of sails and the breaking of masts expressly as accident events, from Basis Plus. Regattas are excluded in Basis, club regattas are covered in Basis Plus and open competitions in Premium.
Two practical points follow for anyone who races, whether that is a club series or an offshore event under a rating rule. First, keep the rig and the sail wardrobe demonstrably in order: a dated rig check by a rigger or a surveyor is the single most useful document in a disputed claim, and the age of standing rigging is a question an underwriter will ask anyway. Second, record the sequence immediately. Time, wind strength from the committee boat or a nearby weather station, what failed first, photographs before anything is cut away or bagged up. A crew member with a phone does more for the outcome than a long letter written three weeks later. It is also worth checking whether the wording treats racing at all, and from what size or rating upwards it wants to be told.
Worth remembering
Always set
are the sails on a race course
Often excluded
is wind acting on set sails
The exclusion was never aimed at racing. It just happens that racing is where the two states coincide all day.
Questions
What owners ask us about this
Why is wind damage to sails excluded at all?
Because sails are consumable items and wind is their working condition. Insurance answers for a sudden event, not for the load the material is designed to take season after season.
Does entering a race have to be declared?
Often yes, and the threshold differs. Some wordings treat club racing as normal use and want to hear about offshore events only, others ask about any organised racing. Read that line before the entry form, not after the finish.
What helps if the classification is disputed?
A current rig check, photographs of the sails at the start of the season, and a written account of the sequence made on the day. Together they separate rig failure from wind on set sails, which is the whole question.
Is the crew covered if someone is hurt?
That is a separate question from the sails and sits in liability rather than in hull. Racing crew arrangements vary between wordings and between class rules, so it is worth settling before the first start rather than after.
Related
Not sure whether you qualify?
Whether it is “Sail and rig damage while racing: what the wording decides” or another question: send us your residence and the flag your boat flies. You will get a straight answer in one email; including a no, if that is the answer.
Was this useful?
