Skip to content

Insurance broker / Insurance questions / Car insurance

Can I keep my car after a total loss?

In short

Yes. You can keep your car after a total loss, because the wreck stays yours. You may repair it yourself or drive on if it is roadworthy. The insurer then deducts the salvage value: with a replacement value of EUR 8,000 and a salvage value of EUR 2,000 you receive EUR 6,000 and keep the car. Under your own cover the deductible comes off as well.

Can I keep my car after a total loss?

What it costs

Worked figures under case law and model terms for a car with EUR 8,000 replacement value and EUR 2,000 salvage value.

ExampleTypical range
Other side at fault, you keep the car and drive on unrepairedEUR 6,000, the car stays yours
Your own Vollkasko, deductible EUR 300, you keep the carEUR 5,700
Other side at fault, repair with used parts for EUR 3,500EUR 6,000, of which EUR 2,500 is left over
Your own Vollkasko, professional repair with invoice for EUR 7,500up to EUR 7,200 after deductible

These amounts are worked examples, a guide value from our quoting practice,

based on the judgments named and the model terms AKB 2015.

The assessment sets the figures in each case; under your own cover your terms apply.

Worked example

Twelve year old estate car, side impact, other driver at fault

The assessor puts a main dealer repair well above the car's value. The owner knows an independent garage that can make it safe with used parts.

Replacement value per assessmentEUR 4,500
Salvage value, regional marketminus EUR 900
Payment from the other side's insurerEUR 3,600
Repair with used partsminus EUR 2,200

The owner keeps driving a car he knows and has EUR 1,400 left. Selling would have given him EUR 3,600 plus EUR 900 from the wreck for another car.

Keeping it is your right; the salvage value is deducted

A total loss only means that a repair would cost more than the car is worth. It does not make the car the insurer's property. You decide whether to sell, scrap, repair or keep driving it.

If you keep it, you do not sell the wreck, so you are not paid the full value. The insurer deducts the salvage value (Restwert), meaning what the damaged car would still fetch. In the end you have the payment plus a car worth about that salvage value.

What you do with the carWhat you receiveWhat to watch
Drive on unrepairedreplacement minus salvage valueonly if roadworthy
Have it repaired cheaplyreplacement minus salvage value, the rest is yoursthe repair must make it safe
Full repair as assessed, other side at faultunder conditions repair costs up to about 130 percentcomplete repair and usually six months of further use
Full repair, your own Vollkaskounder model terms up to replacement value with invoicedeductible, possible loss of no-claims class
Deregister and park itreplacement minus salvage valueparking off public roads

Which salvage value applies

If someone else is at fault and you keep using the car, their insurer may generally only deduct the salvage value your assessor (Gutachter) found for the regional market. The Federal Court of Justice decided this on 06.03.2007 (VI ZR 120/06). You do not have to accept a higher bid from an online buyer.

Under its judgment of 23.11.2010 (VI ZR 35/10) you may rely on a properly prepared assessment and need not ask the insurer before selling. Under your own comprehensive cover your contract applies instead: the model terms define salvage value as the sale value of the damaged car, and insurers often present offers from buyers. Check such an offer before agreeing.

Repairing it your own way

You do not have to spend the money at a garage. If you have it repaired cheaply, for example with used parts, the difference is yours. You only receive more than replacement minus salvage value for a real total loss if the conditions of the 130 percent rule are met, meaning a complete, professional repair as set out in the assessment.

If repair costs are below the replacement value but above replacement minus salvage value, the other side only pays the estimated repair costs without an invoice if you keep using the car for at least six months (VI ZR 35/10). If you repair it yourself and sell it soon after, you get replacement minus salvage value.

Under comprehensive cover the model terms pay up to the replacement value for a complete, professional repair with an invoice, otherwise replacement minus salvage value, in both cases minus the deductible.

Driving on only if roadworthy

An economic total loss can still drive well, for example an old car with hail damage or a dented side. You may only drive it if steering, brakes, lights, tyres and safety systems work. Have a garage or testing station confirm this if load-bearing parts were hit.

Tell your insurer you are keeping the car. Liability cover continues while it is registered. For a later claim under your own cover, the car's value counts with its earlier damage, so you are not paid twice for the same damage.

Deregistering, scrapping or selling

There is no duty to deregister after a total loss. If you deregister, vehicle tax stops and your policy usually moves into free dormant cover (Ruheversicherung), as long as the car is kept in a garage or on private ground.

If you scrap it, the authorised recycler gives you a certificate for the registration office. The insured risk then ends; under the model terms (G.8) the insurer is owed premium only until it learns of this. If you later sell the repaired car, you must tell the buyer about the accident damage.

What changes if you are new to Germany

Assessments and letters from insurers will be in German. If the other side is at fault, you may appoint your own independent assessor at their cost, which also protects you against a salvage value set too high.

Ask your bank or leasing company before deciding: with a lease or a loan secured on the car, they own it and decide. Honestly, keeping only pays off for an older, well kept car you want to drive for years and can repair cheaply.

Step by step

  1. Wait for the assessment and check replacement value, salvage value and repair costs.
  2. Tell the insurer in writing that you are keeping the car.
  3. If the other side is at fault, make sure the regional salvage value from your assessment is used.
  4. Have the car checked for roadworthiness before driving it.
  5. Plan repair, deregistration or scrapping and keep all receipts.

Checklist

  • Assessment with replacement and salvage value
  • The car belongs to you, not a bank or leasing company
  • Roadworthiness confirmed before the first drive
  • Insurer informed that you are keeping the car
  • Repair invoice and photos kept

Common mistakes

  • Driving the damaged car although steering or brakes were hit
  • Accepting a higher salvage offer from the other insurer without checking
  • Assuming a cheap repair qualifies for the 130 percent rule
  • Selling the repaired car later without mentioning the damage

Questions and answers

Frequently asked

Can I just keep driving my car after a total loss?

Yes, if it is roadworthy.

You receive replacement minus salvage value and the car stays yours.

Do I have to deregister the car?

No.

You only need to if you stop driving it or have it scrapped.

Once deregistered, the policy usually rests free of charge.

Do I get less money if I keep the car?

Yes, by the salvage value.

But you have that value in the form of the car,

so you lose nothing as long as the salvage value is set correctly.

Can the insurer demand the wreck?

The other side's insurer cannot,

and the model terms for your own cover do not provide for it either.

It stays yours unless it belongs to a bank or leasing company.

Does the 130 percent rule apply if I repair it myself?

Only for a complete, professional repair as assessed, and only when someone else is at fault.

A repair that just makes the car drivable is not enough.

Sources

NAMMERT insurance broker

Request a quote: Car insurance

We compare insurers and come back to you, in English.

Free; the insurer pays our fee.

1Who is it for?
2Which insurance?

Choose as many as you like. For each one, the details an insurer needs for a quote appear below.

Personal

Business

3Details

Car insurance in Germany (liability, partial and fully comprehensive)

Most precise with the HSN and TSN codes from the registration document

4Your current policy
5How can we reach you?

Free of charge and without obligation. A person will get back to you.

Related questions

Updated

Was this useful?