Skip to content

Insurance broker / Insurance questions / Car insurance

Does insurance pay for an accident on black ice?

In short

Yes. Does insurance pay for an accident on black ice in Germany? Damage to others is always paid by your motor liability insurance. Damage to your own car is only paid by comprehensive cover (Vollkasko), not partial cover. Vollkasko may only cut the payout for gross negligence, such as summer tyres. Then a fine of EUR 60 to 120 and one penalty point also apply.

Does insurance pay for an accident on black ice?

What it costs

Fines in Germany for driving on ice without suitable tyres, and the cost of new tyres.

ExampleTypical range
Driving on ice without suitable tyresEUR 60 and 1 point
With obstruction of othersEUR 80 and 1 point
With danger to othersEUR 100 and 1 point
With an accidentEUR 120 and 1 point
Four new tyres with fitting and balancingon average about EUR 580 to 800

As of November 2026, from the federal fines catalogue and workshop prices.

The deductible and the size of the cut in the worked example are guide values from our quoting

practice, courts decide each case individually.

We check whether your policy waives the gross negligence defence; we obtain the exact quote.

Worked example

Sliding into a crash barrier on refreezing wet road in the morning

Vollkasko with a EUR 500 deductible, winter tyres fitted, damage to your own car EUR 7,000. The cut in the third line is an assumption for illustration.

Crash barrierpaid by your motor liability insurance
Your own car, normal settlement7,000 minus 500 = EUR 6,500
Assumed cut of one quarter for gross negligenceEUR 4,875
With waiver of the gross negligence defenceEUR 6,500

Normally you keep the EUR 500 deductible and the lower no-claims class in liability and Vollkasko. With a cut of one quarter, a further EUR 1,625 is missing. Calculation with guide values.

Who pays for what

For insurers, black ice is not a special case. What matters is whose property was damaged and which cover you have. If you slide into another car, a fence or a crash barrier, your motor liability insurance pays. Under Section 103 of the Insurance Contract Act (VVG) it is only free from liability if the damage was caused intentionally.

Damage to your own car is paid by Vollkasko, which covers accidents, including those you cause yourself. With liability only or Teilkasko you carry your own repair bill.

What happenedWho paysYour share
You slide into another caryour motor liability insurancelower no-claims class in liability
You slide into a crash barrier or treeliability for the barrier or tree, Vollkasko for your cardeductible and lower no-claims class
Another driver slides into your carthe other driver's liability insuranceusually nothing
You only have liability or Teilkaskonobody for your own carthe full damage to your car
Vollkasko, summer tyres caused the crashVollkasko, a cut is possibledepends on how serious the fault was

Why partial cover does not pay

Teilkasko only pays for listed events. In the insurers' model terms these include fire, theft, storm, hail, flooding, glass breakage and collision with game animals. Black ice is not on that list.

A skid is an accident in the sense of the terms: an event that acts suddenly from outside on the car with mechanical force. Accident damage to your own car is a matter for Vollkasko.

When Vollkasko may cut the payout

If you drive carefully and still slide, that is at most simple negligence and fully covered. Only for gross negligence may Vollkasko reduce its payment under Section 81 (2) VVG, in proportion to how serious the fault was.

This mainly comes up with the wrong tyres or a speed that does not suit visible ice. Section 3 (1) of the German road traffic regulations (StVO) requires you to drive only so fast that you keep control of the car at all times and to adapt your speed to the weather.

Courts look closely. The Higher Regional Court of Frankfurt held that driving into a ski area on summer tyres was grossly negligent (case 3 U 186/02). The Hamburg Regional Court made Vollkasko pay in full because the skid on snow could also have happened with winter tyres (case 331 S 137/09). The Higher Regional Court of Cologne awarded the payout after an accident on an icy road although the rear tyres only had about one millimetre of tread left, because the driver could not be shown to have known (case 9 U 175/05, under the law at that time).

Tyres and fines on black ice

Section 2 (3a) StVO only allows driving on black ice, packed snow, slush or frost with tyres approved for these conditions. There is no fixed calendar date, the state of the road is what counts.

Driving in these conditions without suitable tyres costs EUR 60 and one point. If you obstruct others it is EUR 80, if you endanger them EUR 100 and with an accident EUR 120.

Waiver of the gross negligence defence

Many Vollkasko policies waive the right to cut the payout for gross negligence. Then Vollkasko also pays if you were too fast on ice. How far the waiver goes and which cases it leaves out is set out in your policy terms.

If you drive early every morning in winter, check this point when you sign up. In a claim it quickly comes to several thousand euros, as the example shows.

When you do not need Vollkasko for this

For an older car of low value, Vollkasko often costs more over the years than a skid can do to your own car. Liability cover is then enough, and you knowingly carry your own damage.

Prevention still pays off most: suitable tyres, more distance, less speed. With freezing rain, leaving the car at home is the cheapest option.

Step by step

  1. Switch on the hazard lights, put on a high-visibility vest, secure the scene.
  2. Call the police if anyone is injured or a barrier, sign or fence is damaged.
  3. Photograph the road surface, the ice, your tyres and the damage.
  4. Report the accident truthfully to your insurer, the model terms allow one week for this.
  5. If the payout is cut, have it checked whether speed or tyres really caused the accident.

Checklist

  • Tyres with the Alpine symbol on all wheels
  • Vollkasko for new, financed or expensive cars
  • Waiver of the gross negligence defence in your policy
  • Deductible amount known
  • Photos of the road and tyres right after the accident

Common mistakes

  • Relying on partial cover to pay for a skid
  • Treating black ice as an act of God and not adapting your speed
  • Giving the insurer wrong details about tyres or speed
  • Accepting a cut without having the cause checked

Questions and answers

Frequently asked

Does partial cover pay for black ice?

No.

Teilkasko only pays for the events listed in the terms.

A skid is not one of them, for that you need Vollkasko.

Will my no-claims class drop after an accident on ice?

Yes, if liability or Vollkasko pays.

By how much depends on your class and your insurer's table.

Is an accident on black ice grossly negligent?

Not automatically.

If you drive carefully and still slide, you get the full payout.

It becomes critical with summer tyres or clearly excessive speed on visible ice.

Who pays if someone else slides into my car on ice?

The other driver's motor liability insurance.

You need the number plate, the name and ideally photos of the scene.

Is there a fixed speed limit on ice?

No.

You must drive so that you keep control of the car at all times.

Only when visibility is below 50 metres due to fog, snow or rain is the limit 50 km/h.

Are all-season tyres enough on ice?

Yes, if they carry the Alpine symbol, the mountain with a snowflake.

Sources

NAMMERT insurance broker

Request a quote: Car insurance

We compare insurers and come back to you, in English.

Free; the insurer pays our fee.

1Who is it for?
2Which insurance?

Choose as many as you like. For each one, the details an insurer needs for a quote appear below.

Personal

Business

3Details

Car insurance in Germany (liability, partial and fully comprehensive)

Most precise with the HSN and TSN codes from the registration document

4Your current policy
5How can we reach you?

Free of charge and without obligation. A person will get back to you.

Related questions

Updated

Was this useful?