Skip to content

Insurance broker / Insurance questions / Personal liability

Does my liability insurance pay if I damage my flatmate's things?

In short

Does my liability insurance pay if I damage my flatmate's things? In Germany, mostly yes, if you are legally at fault and your flatmate is not insured under the same policy. It does not pay between people on one policy, for relatives living with you such as siblings, and often not for borrowed items. It usually pays the current value: a three year old laptop brings about EUR 450, not EUR 1,200.

Does my liability insurance pay if I damage my flatmate's things?

What it costs

Published prices for personal liability insurance in Germany, 2026.

ExampleTypical range
Single, own policyabout EUR 40 to 120 a year
Couple or familyabout EUR 60 to 180 a year
Cover for borrowed and rented itemsincluded in better tariffs, otherwise about EUR 5 to 20 a year (guide value from our quoting practice)
Excess per claimEUR 0 to 150 (guide value from our quoting practice)

Guide values, November 2026, from published price information.

The add-on for borrowed items and the excess are guide values from our quoting practice;

we obtain the exact quote.

Worked example

Flatmate's laptop knocked off the sofa

Flat share with unrelated people, everyone has their own liability policy. The laptop was three years old and cost EUR 1,200 new.

Price newEUR 1,200
Current value after three yearsabout EUR 450 (guide value from our quoting practice)
Excess in your policyEUR 150
Paid by your insurerabout EUR 300

Your flatmate receives about EUR 450: EUR 300 from your insurer and EUR 150 excess from you. The gap to a new laptop is theirs to carry.

When the insurance pays

German personal liability insurance (Privathaftpflicht) covers you when you damage someone else's property through your own fault and must compensate them under section 823 of the Civil Code (BGB). In a flat share with people you are not related to, your flatmate is a normal third party. Knock over their monitor and your policy pays as it would for a stranger.

Fault matters. If something breaks without any fault on your part, you owe nothing, and your insurer rejects the claim on your behalf.

Situation in the flat shareDoes your policy pay?
You knock your flatmate's laptop off the sofayes, if they are not on your policy
Your sister lives with you and you break her phoneno, relatives in the household are excluded
You borrowed your flatmate's bike and crash itno under the model terms, yes in some tariffs
Your partner is named on your policy and you break their camerano, claims between insured persons
A fire from your room destroys your flatmate's furnitureyes, even after their contents insurer claims it back from you

Three gaps that catch flat shares

Relatives: if you live with siblings, parents or a spouse, the German model terms exclude their claims against you (A1-7.4 AVB PHV).

One contract: if two flatmates are insured under the same policy, for example siblings both covered by their parents' family policy, claims between them are excluded (A1-7.3). The same applies to tariffs that insure everyone in a flat share together.

Borrowed items: damage to things you borrowed, leased or rented is excluded in the model terms (A1-7.5). Many tariffs add it back up to a limit. Without that, you pay for the borrowed bike yourself.

What gets paid

Your insurer pays what you legally owe. For used items that is usually the current value, not the price of a new one.

If your flatmate has their own contents insurance (Hausratversicherung) and it pays after a fire or water damage, their claim against you passes to their insurer (section 86 VVG). That recovery claim then goes to your liability insurer, not to you personally.

Damage to the flat itself

A burn mark in the floor or a broken bathroom door is damage to the rented flat, not to your flatmate's property. The model terms cover damage to rented living space separately (A1-6.6), with their own limit and exclusions such as wear and tear.

Who answers to the landlord depends on the tenancy: main tenant, subtenant or everyone jointly. Check this when you move in.

When you need nothing extra

If you share with people you are not related to, have your own policy and are not on anyone else's, the usual cases are covered. A special flat share tariff adds little.

Students in their first degree are often covered by their parents' policy (A1-2.1.2). That covers damage to unrelated flatmates' things, but not between two siblings on the same parents' policy.

Step by step

  1. Photograph the damage and note the item's age and purchase price.
  2. Do not promise to pay on the spot; say you will report it to your liability insurer.
  3. Check whether your flatmate is related to you or on the same policy.
  4. For borrowed items, look for cover of borrowed property in your terms.
  5. Report the claim promptly and ask your flatmate to put their claim in writing.

Checklist

  • Own policy, or cover through your parents confirmed
  • No sibling or partner on the same policy, or the gap is known
  • Borrowed items included in the tariff
  • Damage to rented living space covered with an adequate limit
  • Everyone knows who is named on the tenancy

Common mistakes

  • Promising your flatmate the full price of a new item
  • Assuming your parents' family policy pays between two siblings
  • Taking out one shared policy for the whole flat without knowing claims between you are then excluded
  • Using borrowed bikes or cameras without cover for borrowed items

Questions and answers

Frequently asked

Does it pay if I share a flat with my brother?

Not for his things.

Relatives living in your household are excluded in the model terms.

Damage to unrelated flatmates' things is covered.

Is one policy for the whole flat share a good idea?

It saves money, but people on the same contract cannot claim against each other through it.

Separate policies cover damage between flatmates.

What if I borrowed my flatmate's bike?

Borrowed items are excluded in the model terms.

Many tariffs add them back up to a limit.

If yours does not, you pay yourself.

Will my flatmate get the price of a new item?

Usually not.

Your insurer pays what you legally owe, which for used items is normally the current value.

Do I have to pay if it was not my fault?

No.

Without fault you are not liable,

and your insurer rejects unjustified claims for you, including your flatmate's.

Am I covered through my parents as a student?

Often yes, while you are unmarried and in your first course of education.

That covers unrelated flatmates' things, but not those of siblings on the same policy.

Sources

NAMMERT insurance broker

Request a quote: Personal liability

We compare insurers and come back to you, in English.

Free; the insurer pays our fee.

1Who is it for?
2Which insurance?

Choose as many as you like. For each one, the details an insurer needs for a quote appear below.

Personal

Business

3Details

Personal liability insurance (Privathaftpflicht)

For example work keys, a drone, a small boat, documents in English

4Your current policy
5How can we reach you?

Free of charge and without obligation. A person will get back to you.

Related questions

Updated

Was this useful?