Skip to content

Insurance broker / Insurance questions / Car insurance

Does insurance pay after an accident in an overloaded car?

In short

Does insurance pay after an accident in an overloaded car? In Germany, yes for the other side: motor liability (Kfz-Haftpflicht) may only refuse for intent. If the overloading helped cause the accident, full cover (Vollkasko) may cut the payout for your own car for gross negligence. On top, fines of EUR 10 to 235 apply from 5 percent over the permitted total weight.

Does insurance pay after an accident in an overloaded car?

What it costs

Fines for overloaded cars and trailers up to 7.5 tonnes in Germany, according to the fines catalogue, plus fees.

ExampleTypical range
More than 5 percent over the permitted total weightEUR 10
More than 10 percentEUR 30
More than 15 percentEUR 35
More than 20 percentEUR 95 and 1 point
More than 25 percentEUR 140 and 1 point
More than 30 percentEUR 235 and 1 point

As of November 2026, from fines tables and guides to the registration certificate.

With administrative fees the notice will be higher.

The damage amounts and the size of the cut in the example are a guide value from our quoting

practice, courts decide case by case.

We check whether your policy waives the gross negligence defence;

we obtain the exact quote for you.

Worked example

Family estate car on the way to the holiday

Permitted total weight 2,100 kilograms, kerb weight 1,500 kilograms. On board: driver, three passengers, full roof box, luggage and two bikes on the rear rack. On the motorway the driver rear ends another car because of the longer braking distance.

Permitted payload600 kg
Actual weight on the weighbridge2,350 kg, about 12 percent too much
FineEUR 30 plus fees
Damage to the other car, paid by liabilityabout EUR 5,000
Own damage EUR 6,000, full cover with EUR 300 deductible and a cut of one quarterabout EUR 4,300 paid out
Same with a waiver of the gross negligence defenceEUR 5,700 paid out

The other driver gets their damage paid in any case. Without a waiver in your policy about EUR 1,700 of your own damage stays with you, with a waiver only the deductible. Calculation with guide values.

Liability pays the other party's damage

If you rear end someone with a fully packed estate car on the way to your holiday, you stay insured. Motor liability insurance (Kfz-Haftpflicht) pays the other party's damage. Under section 103 of the Insurance Contract Act (VVG) it only refuses if you caused the damage intentionally. Overloading is careless, not intentional.

Overloading can, however, increase your share of the blame. A heavy car brakes later, slides out of corners sooner and reacts more slowly when you swerve. If it is clear you would have stopped in time without the extra weight, more of the damage stays with you. Your no-claims class (Schadenfreiheitsklasse) drops as after any liability claim.

When full cover may cut the payout

Damage to your own car is paid by full cover (Vollkasko). If you caused the accident through gross negligence, under section 81 (2) VVG the insurer may reduce its payout in line with how serious your fault was. A few kilos too many is different from a car visibly sagging on its springs.

The insurer has to prove gross negligence and justify the size of the cut. So it must show the extra weight played a part in the accident. If you are stationary and someone drives into you, your load has nothing to do with it.

If your policy waives the gross negligence defence, full cover pays in full even when the car was overloaded, minus the deductible.

SituationMotor liabilityFull cover for your car
Slightly overloaded, accident unrelated to weightpaysusually pays in full
Clearly overloaded, longer braking distance leads to a rear end crashpays, higher share of blame possiblecut for gross negligence possible
Your car is stationary and gets hitnot needed, the other side paysnot needed
Policy waives the gross negligence defencepayspays in full minus deductible

How to work out your payload

Your registration certificate (Zulassungsbescheinigung Teil I) shows the permitted total weight in field F.2 and the kerb weight in field G. The difference is your payload. With a permitted total weight of 2,100 kilograms and a kerb weight of 1,500 kilograms you may load 600 kilograms.

The kerb weight already includes an almost full tank, fluids and a flat 75 kilograms for the driver. All passengers, luggage, roof box and bikes count towards the payload. Optional extras make the car heavier than field G shows; a more precise figure is often in the manufacturer's certificate of conformity.

Fines for driver and keeper

Under section 23 StVO the driver must make sure load and passengers comply with the rules. Under section 31 StVZO the registered keeper must not allow the trip if they know, or should know, that this is not the case. If you lend your car, you can be fined too.

For cars up to 7.5 tonnes fines start at more than 5 percent over the permitted weight. From more than 20 percent you also get a point in the central traffic register in Flensburg.

When you need not worry

Two people with normal luggage rarely bring a car to its limit. It gets critical with four or five adults, a full roof box, a bike rack and drinks crates, in small cars with a low payload and in motorhomes.

If you are unsure, drive to a public weighbridge fully loaded before your holiday. It costs little and gives you clarity before the police or an assessor do the maths.

Step by step

  1. Read fields F.2 and G in your registration certificate and work out the payload.
  2. Roughly add up passengers, luggage, roof box and bikes, counting the driver only with their weight above 75 kilograms.
  3. If in doubt, drive to a public weighbridge fully loaded.
  4. Check your policy terms to see whether full cover waives the gross negligence defence.
  5. After an accident, state truthfully what was loaded and only accept a cut with reasons given.

Checklist

  • Payload from field F.2 minus field G known
  • Roof load and nose weight according to the owner's manual respected
  • Heavy luggage stowed low and close to the rear seat
  • Tyre pressure raised for full load
  • Full cover with a waiver of the gross negligence defence

Common mistakes

  • Believing that overloading cancels all insurance cover
  • Taking the kerb weight from the brochure instead of field G
  • Forgetting the roof box, bike rack and drinks when adding up
  • Lending the fully loaded car and thinking only the driver is responsible

Questions and answers

Frequently asked

Does liability pay if my car was overloaded?

Yes.

The other party gets their damage paid.

Motor liability may only refuse for intent.

How much can I load?

Permitted total weight from field F.2 minus kerb weight from field G.

The driver at 75 kilograms is already included.

When is there a fine?

For cars from more than 5 percent over the permitted total weight.

From more than 20 percent you also get a point.

Does full cover cut the payout for every overload?

No.

It may only cut if there was gross negligence and the extra weight helped cause the accident.

The insurer has to justify this.

Can I be fined as the keeper if someone else drove?

Yes, that is possible.

The keeper must not allow the trip if they know or should know that load or passengers do not

comply with the rules.

Does this also apply to a trailer?

Yes, a trailer has its own permitted total weight, and fines up to 2 tonnes match those for cars.

The towing limit and nose weight of the towing car also count.

Sources

NAMMERT insurance broker

Request a quote: Car insurance

We compare insurers and come back to you, in English.

Free; the insurer pays our fee.

1Who is it for?
2Which insurance?

Choose as many as you like. For each one, the details an insurer needs for a quote appear below.

Personal

Business

3Details

Car insurance in Germany (liability, partial and fully comprehensive)

Most precise with the HSN and TSN codes from the registration document

4Your current policy
5How can we reach you?

Free of charge and without obligation. A person will get back to you.

Related questions

Updated

Was this useful?