Skip to content

Insurance broker / Insurance questions / Car insurance

Who pays for an accident caused by a badly secured load in Germany?

In short

Who pays for an accident caused by a badly secured load in Germany? Damage to others is paid by your motor liability insurance, even for gross negligence, but you lose no-claims classes. Your own car is paid only by comprehensive cover (Vollkasko), which may cut the payout for gross negligence. The load itself is not insured. Fines run from EUR 35 to 75, with a penalty point if others were endangered.

Who pays for an accident caused by a badly secured load in Germany?

What it costs

Fines from the current German catalogue and published averages, as of November 2026.

ExampleTypical range
Load not stowed safely, driverEUR 35, endangering others EUR 60 and 1 point, accident EUR 75 and 1 point
Keeper allows a trip with an unsafe loadEUR 135 to 200 and 1 point
Average property claim on a car paid by insurersabout EUR 4,600
Liability plus comprehensive cover, age 35, SF 10, compact carabout EUR 500 to 1,200 a year

Fines plus fees and costs.

The average claim comes from an insurance industry analysis of November 2026.

The claim amounts and the reduction rate in the worked example are guide values from our quoting

practice; in a dispute, courts decide each case.

Whether your policy waives the gross negligence defence is something we check;

we obtain the exact quote.

Worked example

Moving house in an estate car, washing machine unsecured

The washing machine stands loose in the boot. On a roundabout it slides sideways, the driver briefly loses control and scrapes a parked car. He has liability and comprehensive cover with a EUR 300 deductible.

Damage to the parked car, paid by liabilityabout EUR 4,600
Own damage EUR 6,000, comprehensive cover cuts by halfabout EUR 2,850 paid
Same with a waiver of the gross negligence defenceEUR 5,700 paid
Broken washing machineEUR 0 from motor insurance
FineEUR 75 and 1 point

The owner of the parked car is paid in any case. Without a waiver you carry about EUR 3,150 on your own car, with a waiver only the deductible. Both liability and comprehensive cover are downgraded. Calculation with guide values.

Damage to others: your liability insurance pays

If a roof box lands on the Autobahn, a plank slides off your trailer or crates of drinks hit your passengers when you brake, you are liable as the keeper for damage caused by running your car (section 7 StVG). That is what compulsory motor liability (Kfz-Haftpflicht) is for. It pays the injured party even if the load was carelessly packed. Under section 103 VVG it is only free from liability where damage is caused intentionally.

The cost comes later: a paid liability claim moves you down the no-claims scale (SF-Klasse), and your premium rises for several years. Injured passengers are paid by liability too. Your own injuries as the driver are not, unless you have driver cover (Fahrerschutz).

What is damagedWho paysWhat to watch
Car or person hit by your loadyour motor liability insuranceno-claims downgrade
Injured passengers in your caryour motor liability insuranceyour own injuries as driver only with driver cover
Your car after an accident caused by the loadyour comprehensive covercut for gross negligence unless your policy waives it
Your car, only because the load slid around insidenobodyan operating damage under the model terms, not an accident
The load itself, such as a washing machine or bikesno motor insuranceexcept clothing, glasses and luggage of passengers on passenger trips

Your own car: comprehensive cover only, and not always in full

Partial cover (Teilkasko) does not help here, because accidents are not among its events. If a shifting load makes you leave the road or hit another car, only comprehensive cover pays, minus your deductible.

If the load was left unsecured through gross negligence and that caused the crash, the insurer may cut the payout under section 81(2) VVG in line with the degree of fault. It has to prove this. Many newer policies waive this defence, so comprehensive cover then pays in full, though alcohol and drugs are usually excluded.

One limit many people miss: if the load damages the car only from the inside, for example a box that tears the rear seat when you brake, the German model terms treat this as operating damage, not an accident. You pay for that yourself.

Roof box, bike rack and trailer

The same rule applies to a roof box or bike rack as to the boot: if the box or bikes fall onto the road and damage another car, your liability insurance pays. The box contents and the bikes are not replaced by motor insurance. Check the permitted roof load in the owner's manual, which includes the rack and box.

Under the model terms, the towing car's liability cover extends to an attached trailer, even if it comes loose while driving. Damage to your own trailer and the load on it is not paid. For that you would need separate cover for the trailer.

Fines and penalty points

Section 22 of the German road traffic rules (StVO) requires loads to stay in place even under full braking or a sudden swerve. A load that is not stowed safely costs the driver EUR 35, EUR 60 and one point if others are endangered, and EUR 75 and one point if there is an accident.

The keeper can be fined too for allowing the trip although the load seriously affects road safety: EUR 135, EUR 165 with danger to others, EUR 200 with an accident, each with one point. This can hit you when you lend your loaded car to someone.

When you need not worry

Carrying shopping in the boot with heavy items low and against the rear seat is no special risk. Trouble starts with loose items on the back seat, heavy objects without straps, open trailers without a net and overloaded roof boxes.

If you only have liability cover, the waiver of the gross negligence defence does not matter for this case, because liability pays third parties anyway. For a new, financed or leased car with comprehensive cover it belongs in the contract.

Step by step

  1. Put heavy items low and right against the rear seat, and use a dog guard or net in an estate car.
  2. Fix loose items with lashing straps to the eyelets in the boot.
  3. Check the roof load in the owner's manual and count the box and rack.
  4. Strap down loads on a trailer and cover open beds with a net or tarpaulin.
  5. After an accident describe what happened honestly and only accept a cut in comprehensive cover with reasons.

Checklist

  • Nothing heavy loose on the back seat or parcel shelf
  • Lashing straps or a net in the car
  • Roof load and nose weight respected
  • Comprehensive cover with a waiver of the gross negligence defence
  • Driver cover for your own injuries checked

Common mistakes

  • Thinking nobody pays the other driver if the load was unsecured
  • Expecting motor insurance to replace the goods you carried
  • Reporting damage inside the car from a sliding load as a comprehensive claim
  • Lending your loaded car and assuming only the driver is responsible

Questions and answers

Frequently asked

Does liability insurance pay if my load damages another car?

Yes.

The injured party is paid even for gross negligence; liability may only refuse for intent.

You are then downgraded.

Does comprehensive cover pay for my car if the load was not secured?

In principle yes, minus the deductible.

If that was grossly negligent and caused the crash,

the insurer may cut the payout unless your policy waives that defence.

Who pays for the broken load?

Not motor insurance.

Only items passengers normally carry are included, such as clothing,

glasses or luggage on passenger trips.

What if something falls from the car in front onto mine?

Then the other car's motor liability insurance pays your damage.

Note the number plate, take photos and find witnesses.

How much is the fine for an unsecured load in Germany?

For the driver EUR 35, EUR 60 with danger to others, EUR 75 with an accident,

the last two with one point.

The keeper may also pay EUR 135 to 200.

Is my trailer covered by the car's insurance?

For damage to others yes, while it is attached.

The trailer itself and the load on it are not paid by liability.

Does partial cover pay if the load breaks a window?

Glass breakage is covered by partial cover minus the deductible and costs no no-claims class.

Other damage from your own load is not covered by it.

Sources

NAMMERT insurance broker

Request a quote: Car insurance

We compare insurers and come back to you, in English.

Free; the insurer pays our fee.

1Who is it for?
2Which insurance?

Choose as many as you like. For each one, the details an insurer needs for a quote appear below.

Personal

Business

3Details

Car insurance in Germany (liability, partial and fully comprehensive)

Most precise with the HSN and TSN codes from the registration document

4Your current policy
5How can we reach you?

Free of charge and without obligation. A person will get back to you.

Related questions

Updated

Was this useful?