Skip to content

Insurance broker / Insurance questions / Car insurance

Who pays for damage to my car in a multi-storey car park in Germany?

In short

Who pays for damage to my car in a multi-storey car park in Germany? If the other driver is known, their motor liability insurer. If not, only your comprehensive cover (Vollkasko), minus the deductible. The operator is only liable for its own failures, such as a faulty barrier, not for every dent other customers cause. If you scrape a pillar yourself, only Vollkasko pays.

Who pays for damage to my car in a multi-storey car park in Germany?

What it costs

Repair costs for typical parking dents from a German workshop survey, 2026.

ExampleTypical range
Small scratch or dent without electronicsabout EUR 1,000 to 2,500
Rear bumper with parking sensorsabout EUR 2,100 to 5,100
Front bumper and headlight, depending on modelabout EUR 3,000 to 8,000
Deductible on comprehensive coverusually EUR 300 to 500

Workshop prices from a market survey published in February 2026.

The deductible and the figures in the worked example are guide values from our quoting practice.

Your amount depends on model, workshop and policy.

Worked example

Unknown driver dents your car in a car park, you have Vollkasko

The rear bumper with two sensors has to be replaced. This is how you work out whether claiming is worth it.

Repair according to the quoteEUR 2,600
Your deductibleEUR 300
Extra premium after the downgrade, three years in totalabout EUR 600
Your cost if you claimabout EUR 900

Claiming pays off: you pay around EUR 900 instead of EUR 2,600. For a repair below about EUR 1,000, paying yourself would be cheaper.

Four situations, four payers

Car parks are tight, and most damage happens while parking or pulling out. Who pays depends on who caused the damage and whether they can be identified.

Damage caused by another customer is legally an ordinary accident. Their liability insurer pays and your own policy is not affected. If they cannot be traced, only Vollkasko helps, because partial cover does not pay for collisions.

SituationWho paysYour share
Another customer damaged your car and is knowntheir motor liability insurernothing
Culprit unknown, you have Vollkaskoyour Vollkaskodeductible and a lower no-claims class
Culprit unknown, only liability or Teilkaskonobodythe whole repair
Faulty barrier, roller door or ceiling partthe operator or its insurernothing, if you can prove the defect
You scrape a pillar, wall or ramp yourselfyour Vollkasko for your car, your liability cover for the buildingdeductible and a lower no-claims class

When the operator is liable

According to a Federal Court of Justice ruling of 19 December 2025 (V ZR 44/25), parking for a fee generally creates a rental contract for a space. The operator owes you a safe space, but not someone watching your car.

It is liable if it breaches its own duties: a barrier that drops onto your car for no reason, a jammed roller door, falling ceiling parts or an unsecured building site. In the first instance you carry the burden of proof, so photos, witnesses and an immediate report at the pay desk are vital.

Many car parks exclude liability in their terms. Under § 309 no. 7 of the Civil Code (BGB), however, such an exclusion in standard terms is void for gross negligence, intent and for injury to people.

Collisions in the driving lanes

In 2022 the Federal Court of Justice ruled (VI ZR 344/21) that the right before left rule only applies in car parks where the lanes clearly look like roads. Otherwise everyone has to drive with particular care and consideration.

If both cars were moving and nobody can prove who stopped first, liability is often split. In that case both drivers were too fast and the courts divided it 70 to 30. Your own share of the damage to your own car is then only paid by Vollkasko.

Claim or pay yourself

Vollkasko lowers your no-claims class after every claim, regardless of the amount. If the repair costs only a little more than the deductible, the higher premium over the following years often exceeds the damage. Many insurers let you buy back a claim within a set period.

Small dents have become expensive because bumpers now carry sensors and cameras. Get a quote first, then do the maths.

If you hit another car yourself

Wait a reasonable time and report the damage at the pay desk or to the police if nobody turns up. A note under the wiper is not enough in Germany and does not protect you from prosecution for leaving the scene of an accident under § 142 of the Criminal Code (StGB).

Car parks often have cameras. If you drive off and are traced later, you risk a criminal penalty and your liability insurer may recover part of what it paid from you.

Step by step

  1. Photograph the damage before you drive out, including the bay number and surroundings.
  2. Report it immediately at the pay desk or control room and ask them to secure the camera footage.
  3. Look for witnesses and a note on the windscreen; if the culprit drove off, report it to the police.
  4. If a defect in the car park caused the damage, claim from the operator in writing.
  5. Get a repair quote and only then decide whether to use your Vollkasko.

Checklist

  • Photos of the damage and the parking position
  • Parking ticket or payment receipt kept
  • Report to staff with the time noted
  • Written request to secure the video footage
  • Police report if the culprit is unknown
  • Vollkasko and deductible checked

Common mistakes

  • Driving home first and reporting later, so you cannot prove where the damage happened
  • Holding the operator responsible for every dent, although it does not owe you guarding
  • Claiming small damage on Vollkasko although the downgrade costs more
  • Leaving only a note after hitting another car and driving off

Questions and answers

Frequently asked

Does the car park operator pay for scratches?

Usually not if another customer caused them.

It is liable if it breached its own duties, for example with faulty equipment.

Does Teilkasko pay for damage in a car park?

Only in its own cases such as theft, fire or broken glass.

It does not pay when another car dented yours.

Can the operator exclude all liability?

No.

Under § 309 no.

7 BGB an exclusion in standard terms is void for gross negligence, intent and injury to people.

What should I do if the car park has cameras?

Ask straight away for the footage to be secured and report the incident to the police,

so it is not overwritten in the normal cycle.

Who pays if I hit a pillar?

Your own car only by Vollkasko.

Damage to the pillar or wall is paid by your motor liability insurance.

Does right before left apply in a car park?

Only on lanes that clearly look like roads.

Otherwise mutual consideration applies, and unclear cases often end in a split.

Sources

NAMMERT insurance broker

Request a quote: Car insurance

We compare insurers and come back to you, in English.

Free; the insurer pays our fee.

1Who is it for?
2Which insurance?

Choose as many as you like. For each one, the details an insurer needs for a quote appear below.

Personal

Business

3Details

Car insurance in Germany (liability, partial and fully comprehensive)

Most precise with the HSN and TSN codes from the registration document

4Your current policy
5How can we reach you?

Free of charge and without obligation. A person will get back to you.

Related questions

Updated

Was this useful?