Home / For international owners / Cover
Do later improvements to the wording reach an old policy?
Short answer
A boat policy often runs for twenty years,
and the wording behind it is rewritten several times in that period.
Which version applies to a contract signed long ago is decided by a clause very few owners ever
read.
Boat policies are long lived. It is entirely normal for the same contract to run ten, twenty or thirty years, through two boats and three brokers, while the wording behind it is redrafted several times. The question that follows is simple and almost never asked at inception: years later, which version governs a claim, the one printed when the contract started or the current one. Without a clause saying otherwise, it is the older one, and an older wording can sit a long way behind what the market considers normal by then.
Two clauses exist to catch that, and they are regularly confused. A benefits guarantee promises that the cover will not fall behind a defined benchmark, often the wording of a named competitor or a market standard. An update guarantee promises that later improvements made by the same insurer apply to the existing contract without an extra charge. The second is the one that matters in practice, because it works on its own. Our Premium tier carries it: if the wording for new business is changed only to your advantage and without extra premium, the new wording applies to your contract at once. The first only helps the owner who notices the shortfall, compares the two documents and then argues the point, which in reality means at the worst possible moment, after a loss.
So when comparing quotes it is worth asking three things rather than one. Is there such a clause at all. Does it apply without an additional premium. And what does it carve out. Almost every version excludes changes that come with a price increase, and separately agreed optional sections. If there is no clause, the remedy is manual but effective: every few years, ask in writing whether the contract can be moved onto the current wording, and check at the same time whether the no claims record and the price move with it. That request costs a phone call and succeeds more often than most owners expect. One thing it cannot do is reach backwards. The version in force on the day of the incident is the one that settles the claim, not the version in force on the day the money is paid.
Worth remembering
Twenty years
is a normal life for a boat policy
The booklet
stays as old as the day it was signed
Whether the improvements of 2030 reach the contract is decided by a clause agreed today.
Questions
What owners ask us about this
Can a contract simply be moved onto the current wording?
Asking costs nothing, and many insurers will do it on request. Check what moves with it, because a new wording occasionally arrives together with a new price or a recalculated no claims record.
Does an improvement apply to a loss that already happened?
No. What governs a claim is the wording in force at the time of the incident, not the wording in force when the claim is finally settled. That is why the date of loss matters more than the date of the invoice.
Is a benefits guarantee the same as an update guarantee?
No, and the difference is practical. A benefits guarantee measures the cover against an outside benchmark and has to be invoked. An update guarantee moves the contract forward by itself when the insurer improves its own wording.
What is usually carved out of such a clause?
Changes that come with a higher premium, and optional sections that have to be agreed separately. In other words, improvements that are free tend to follow, improvements that are paid for do not.
Related
Not sure whether you qualify?
Whether it is “Do later improvements to the wording reach an old policy?” or another question: send us your residence and the flag your boat flies. You will get a straight answer in one email; including a no, if that is the answer.
Was this useful?
